Re:Judge: Fifth Amendment doesn't protect encrypted hard drives
by mc32 on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @03:35PM
(#3506618)
>I'm wondering what the legal ramifications might be if you set a secondary key that would wipe the drive
Destruction of evidence. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spoliation_of_evidence
Re:Judge: Fifth Amendment doesn't protect encrypted hard drives
by talmand on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @03:40PM
(#3506644)
Oh, I get that, I'm not saying it's a way to avoid the ramifications, I'm just wondering what they are.
I have to say that I somewhat agree with the ruling because there are similar situations with physical objects, not true one-to-one but they are there. I'm just wondering how the courts would react to the destruction of digital evidence that was not directly initiated by the defendant, but indirectly by preparing for the possibility.
Re:Judge: Fifth Amendment doesn't protect encrypted hard drives
by Simucal on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @04:38PM
(#3506968)
These "wipe the drive" decoy password scenarios would never work in real life unless their forensics team was really inept.
There would be copies made and the drive that has the encrypted volume would likely be accessed with a "Write Blocker" forensic device, or in a virtual environment, etc.
This technique would only tip your hand that the volume contents changed after entering the password.
Re:Judge: Fifth Amendment doesn't protect encrypted hard drives
by slowpoke on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @09:26PM
(#3508100)
A technical solution to this might be a form of encryption the requires a writable disk to actually decrypt anything. I don't know if that is possible, but it would effectively prevent these safeguards to work. And remember, you don't need to wipe the entire drive. Changing a few random bits in the decryption key would already forever turn the drive contents into unreadable garbage.
I'm wondering what the legal ramifications might be if you set a secondary key that would wipe the drive in the most secure method possible and then provide that key. Or even the alternate boot sequence as suggested.