News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by ineptech on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @07:31PM (#35063532)
Lacking a technical fix, isn't this fundamentally a KYC problem? There's an arms race of fraud against banks and financial companies, but it seems like they're managing okay.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @08:13PM (#35063869)
Yes. Holding online advertising to KYC standards would lock most advertisers out of the ecosystem. But most aren't bad actors.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by ineptech on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @08:42PM (#35064075)
According to whom? The organization that can't distinguish bad actors from good? I mean, you may be right, but he point is, they could do it, they just choose not to because it would be unprofitable.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @08:48PM (#35064125)
They chose not to because it would lock most advertisers out. That's pretty much counter to everyone's goals. It's analogous to the "stop crime by jailing all of Texas" solution.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by manigandham on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @09:12PM (#35064327)
That makes no sense. It seems you're confused about KYC. It's a screening process that blocks known bad actors (eg: in finance that is anyone convicted of certain crimes, on watchlists, denied by regions or sanctions, etc). Most advertisers would not be affected at all.

By the way, this is already done since Google does check advertiser accounts against various sanctions and watchlists as part of dosing business in every country they operate in.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @09:22PM (#35064397)
So if it's already done, it's not sufficient to stop bad advertisers?
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by manigandham on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @11:40PM (#35065324)
It’s done for governmental and judicial issues like not working with terrorist organizations. It’s not accounting for bad advertiser history and related behaviors and connections.

The point is that it’s not a resource or scale issue, it’s a profit and incentives issue as I said before.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @10:54AM (#35070553)
So a credit score but for the ad industry.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by manigandham on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @08:39PM (#35064059)
Why would it lock out most advertisers?
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @08:52PM (#35064153)
Because Google (like other online advertisers and most online services) doesn't have any tighter KYC restrictions than accepting a valid credit card (which, we assume, has already been KYC'd by a bank).

Requiring bank-scale KYC on top of that to also work with the advertisers would cut the 4 million advertisers Google currently serves down to a tiny fraction of that (if for no other reason than they don't have infrastructure to background-vet 4 million customers; they don't currently).

Perhaps this is the right approach. It would end the days of being able to set up an advertising account in a few hours. Perhaps that's not needed anymore.

(This would, of course, mean people giving even more PII to Google. However one feels about that).

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by manigandham on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @09:10PM (#35064310)
> "doesn't have any tighter KYC restrictions"

Yes that's the problem.

> "Requiring bank-scale KYC..."

Nobody said that. The KYC part is an analogy to the financial industry to use procedures to screen out bad actors. But it doesn't need the same requirements.

> " they don't have infrastructure to background-vet 4 million customers"

KYC is not difficult. Again, banks and finance companies which are far smaller than Google do this all the time, for all of their customers and anyone involved in transactions. This is 100s of millions of clients.

> "Perhaps this is the right approach."

This approach is far more nuanced than the binary outcome you're interpreting. There are ad and account approvals already. There are different scales requiring different support and sales already. Having more intensive checks as the spending scales is a very simple and effective strategy that can be applied today.

The company doesn't care about the number of customers, it cares about the revenue against potential risk (just like every other every business), and currently the risk is acceptable for these ads and advertisers to continue.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by ineptech on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @12:30AM (#35065594)
There's probably some middle ground between "bank-scale KYC" and "people don't steal credit card numbers, do they?". You really think their current process can't be improved on? With all of their billions, their PhDs, their regulatory capture, finding a way to let in most of the real advertisers while keeping out the scammers isn't just too expensive, it's literally impossible? Despite the fact that they have a near monopoly and the legitimate advertisers will jump through almost any hoop imaginable?
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by JohnFen on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @11:02AM (#35070653)
> It would end the days of being able to set up an advertising account in a few hours. Perhaps that's not needed anymore.

That ability was never needed and was never a good idea.