News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by JohnFen on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @05:28PM (#35062171)
I already mentioned that it doesn't scale.

The real issue, IMO, is that Google's business model is just fundamentally bad. But Google is large enough that it doesn't matter. They're like a large industrial polluter poisoning the lands and arguing that there's nothing they can effectively do about it because addressing the problem would be bad for their business.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @05:37PM (#35062299)
Well, their business and the business of everyone that advertises online. So it comes back to "Should we all pound and because of a (statistically) few bad actors?"

Firefox advertises at the top of "download browser." Should we cede their ability to be found to whoever Google thinks should be at the top of that organic result? Because by user numbers alone, it probably won't be Firefox!

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by JohnFen on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @05:46PM (#35062399)
I think a strong case can be made that if a business cannot operate without causing harm to unconsenting others, it should not be operating.

> because of a (statistically) few bad actors?

It doesn't actually matter how many or few bad actors there are. What matters is how much harm is being done.

I'm not sure what your point is about Firefox, but in general, it doesn't matter if mitigating the harm Google's ad system does adversely affects Firefox or any other advertiser.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @05:57PM (#35062529)
Who are the unconsenting others? The people who chose to trust a Google ad?

I'm not sure what consent means if it doesn't mean "user clicked on a result after asking Google for results." The backstop here is the user doesn't come back because they got screwed by Google, not that some third-party makes that decision for people.

But yes, I suspect if Google can't get on top of this problem they'll lose their leadership position in search.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by JohnFen on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @06:15PM (#35062724)
> I'm not sure what consent means if it doesn't mean "user clicked on a result after asking Google for results."

First, I'm talking about ads, not search results. Although Google conflates the two as much as they can get away with, and people often get confused as to which is which.

I can't imagine how clicking on an ad can be interpreted as consent to being exposed to malware. In order to be considered "consent", the person has to be fully and accurately informed of what they're being asked to consent to.

> The backstop here is the user doesn't come back because they got screwed by Google

I truly wish we lived in a world where that could be expected.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @06:28PM (#35062894)
I don't see why we wouldn't expect it. Wouldn't be worth talking about if it wasn't a possibility.

Google dethroned search vendors before them and they aren't bulletproof. If they are, might as well pack up DDG and everything else right now. Shut off the servers and decrease the greenhouse gas emissions, right?

No, I think the backstop here is that DDG has a wonderful opportunity to be the search engine where you don't have to worry about getting vended malware via an ad above the first organic result.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by taneq on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @07:43PM (#35076861)
We’ve all paid to drink from this punch bowl, should we ask for a refund just because a few bad actors pissed in it?
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by tracker1 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @03:25PM (#35074281)
It can scale just fine... Green certs for SSL have been able to scale just fine... why, you pay for it. Advertisers should have to pay for verification.. it doesn't have to be an excessive fee, and can be connected to a bank account in good standing. Holding an amount in escrow during the first year could help as well.

Why shouldn't advertisers have to clear the same hurdle as opening a bank account in most western countries?