News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by deminature on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:51PM (#35061777)
Why are they accepting ads for a product from anyone but the verified maker of the product in the first place? Surely there's budget in that river of ad money to do the most basic due diligence?
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:54PM (#35061812)
Being allowed to advertise on someone else's brand, trademark, etc. has been pretty much a cornerstone of online advertising since the birth of online advertising. It's justified as the way mom-and-pops have any hope at all of competing with big-box names; otherwise, Dan's Local Electronics couldn't show up on searches for Best Buy as a potential micro-targeted local alternative.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by deminature on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:56PM (#35061830)
I'm not talking about advertising on someone else's brand, I'm talking about advertising AS someone else's brand, or malicious impersonation. The most basic vetting of advertising would catch this, but apparently this is not occurring.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @05:03PM (#35061911)
Our observation of what is occurring doesn't match what is occurring.

Here's how the vetting you're imagining works:

1. The automated system goes to the advertised site. But Google's IPs are public knowledge, so the site vends a "safe" version to Google's checkers.

2. If Google sends a human being? Same story. That human's coming from a Google IP.

3. Google has a small set of non-Google IPs that they privately use for checking. This process seems to have broken down. My guess is malvertisers have caught wise and have managed to build a good list of those IPs to cloak against Google's back- and side-channel verifies too.

In terms of the actual ad copy: I suspect a lot of that is checked automatically, and the rest is often checked by contractors. So you're trying to solve the "Build an AI to understand when something is confusing" problem. There's probably room for improvement here, but it's not as surprising as I wish it were that stuff slips through the cracks at that layer.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by Nextgrid on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @06:32PM (#35062931)
> But Google's IPs are public knowledge

You're telling me that even though attackers of various sophistication are able to get clean, residential IPs all the time for nefarious purposes, Google can't do the same? Come on. It's not that they can't, it's that they don't care.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @07:41PM (#35063631)
They definitely can. You underestimate how quickly they are identified as Google ad-check bots by the actors who don't want to be seen.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by basch on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:54PM (#35061810)
Is that extortion? Pay us or malware displaces you as the first thing people see?

That said, it’s pretty common to get a competitor ad above the top search result.

Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:55PM (#35061819)
It's not "extortion" so much as "stupid." "Pay us or we'll convince people our search results are crap" is a really bad business model.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by basch on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:59PM (#35061881)
You know how many people will think “teamviewer or Firefox must have gotten hacked” before “google sent me to a bad site” OR not notice for days and have no idea where it came from?
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by pixl97 on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @04:57PM (#35061848)
Because in the vast majority if markets the manufacturer is not the reseller. This is even true in many places in the software market.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by Nextgrid on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @06:34PM (#35062961)
True, but it seems like in the case of Blender, there is no reseller, so an easy solution is to literally blacklist the word "Blender" (when it comes to software - I'm sure they have semantic analysis behind the scenes to differentiate Blender the 3D software vs a smoothie blender). The ban can be reversed if an official from the Blender project reaches out (if they ever need to advertise for example).
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by shadowgovt on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @07:42PM (#35063636)
So nobody's allowed to advertise a better 3d modeling option on searches for "blender?"
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by Nextgrid on Tuesday March 07, 2023 @07:52PM (#35063713)
You can allow it as targeting, but disallow the word "Blender" in the ad copy, which is what these scams would use to misrepresent themselves and trick the user into downloading malware.
Re:Google ads malvertising is targeting open source software by pixl97 on Wednesday March 08, 2023 @09:11AM (#35069126)
Using your competitors name is legal in US advertising