http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=moving+from+Mountain+Vi...
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=moving+from+San+Fransis...
This is on the top of the fact that we pay, in total, around 50% tax.
Housing is more expensive in SV, but everything else is much cheaper than where I'm from. Are these numbers accurate? Because if they are, then, pardon me for being blunt, you guys are really whining a lot. You must be living in one of the places on Earth with the highest ratio of income to expenses. That the cost of living is higher than in the US in general doesn't really seem like an argument to me. You're pretty much swimming in money over there.
The tax difference is much lower than Norwegians like to think (what would Norwegians do if there was no excuse for complaining about high taxes). I calculated my Norwegian tax, UK tax and what I'd pay in California including VAT / sales tax, and while Norway came up on top, on my - way above average salary - total tax came out at about 39% for Oslo, and about 34% for California, and about 36% or so in the UK, before taking into consideration things like difference in health care coverage.
There are places in the US where the tax gap compared to Norway is large, but California isn't it.
It's hard to end up paying around 50% tax in Norway even including what you pay in VAT, unless you make a huge multiple of average salaries. You could of course add in employers payroll taxes ("arbeidsgiveravgift"; but in that case, don't forget to do that for California as well), but if so, you're considering it part of your income and need to adjust gross salary up accordingly too - I see people try to add in payroll taxes to inflate the tax number, but nobody takes the payroll taxes into consideration when comparing salaries, or when negotiating them.
The marginal income tax band is capped below 50% (when you add in state income tax, federal income tax and local taxes, the marginal tax rates in some US locations is not that far away either), and unless your salary is way above average and you spend it all, even with the 25% VAT adds up to much less because most people simply don't spend that much of their salary on buying top rated goods. On top of that, deductions reduce the gap. Of course if you live in the cheapest place possible and spend all your remaining money on highly taxed goods like alcohol and cigarettes and warm your house with petroleum, then, yes, you may manage to end up paying 50% or more to the government.
That said, overall you'd probably come out better in SF on the same salary due to the cost of goods and services. But the "we pay so much tax" thing from fellow Norwegians is a pet peeve of mine, after I moved to the UK, and, surprise, didn't actually pay much less tax.
This is particularly true for housing, since there's more to finding a place to live than the median price of a rental. The "median" apartment in SF is likely a studio in the Tenderloin (e.g., stabby stabby!). It doesn't take into account what is being rented, nor where it is, nor transportation, nor any other crucial factors. The metric "average price of a rental apartment" is pretty much as useless as can be.
Take this for example, I moved from Seattle to SF not too long ago:
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=moving+from+San+Fransis...
According to Wolfram, housing in Seattle is about half of SF. Except, if you actually shop in both markets, you will find that in Seattle you'll find a big 1BR in a nice part of town, with a doorman, elevators, probably nice shared facilities like gyms, hot tubs, BBQs, and saunas.
For 2x that in SF you'll find a 1BR in a crappy part of town, not close to mass transit, built at the turn of the century, comes with a book full of asbestos and lead-paint warnings, and forget about the gym, you probably won't even have your own damn washing machine in the flat.
So yeah, apples to oranges really. Cost of living calculators can go burn in hell.
The most noticeable thing is that the lowest end of the economy seems to run on cheap Hispanic labour; food especially. Fuel and general goods are cheaper, from probable combination of lower taxes, more competition and scale from the large market.
Major roads are in surprisingly poor surface condition; back roads in the Santa Cruz mountains are frequently narrow and dangerously uneven. The whole place generally has a feel of being hastily put together in a few years; which it has, more or less, from the combination of earthquakes and its American youth.
Consider the lack of density outside of central San Francisco - how spread out everything is - and it seems clear that infrastructure investment is thinned out over the larger area.
It's a nice place to live if you like being outdoors, but if you don't have a lot of money you'll need private transport to get to a decent bit of that outdoors.
On careful consideration, I prefer London. I end up with a lower salary, a similar cost of accommodation, I'm a lot lower in the social and financial "pecking order" owing to finance industry etc., but I have a lot more choice of things to do.
[Edit: To the GP, I'm not sure I would want to trade places. Work-life balance is very important to me, and is something that is worth quite a bit of money to me. It seems like most Americans work very long hours with few holidays, although you do seem to get paid a lot. I wouldn't want to settle down in the US, but it might be nice to try for a couple of years.]
Furthermore there's a significant amount of "affordable housing" and public projects sitting on huge multi-billion dollar lots. All that contributes to artificially high prices for everyone else.
Most of San Francisco's woes directly result from policy-makers who don't understand basic Economics.
Most startup people seem to want to live in the Mission or other older areas, even if they work in SoMA. (something I don't understand; I like the new buildings in SoMA)
But what about tenants? The San Francisco Tenants Union says, "most [San Francisco] tenants are covered by rent control." [1]
I couldn't find recent numbers, but the San Francisco Rent Board's 2002 Tenant Survey Summary Report [2] says two-thirds of survey respondents’ units were rent-controlled and 10% were market rate:
San Francisco’s rental housing stock is still dominated by rent controlled units. Over two thirds of survey respondents’ units were classified as rent controlled; 13 percent were subsidized or assisted, 10 percent were market rate and the remainder were either occupied by close relatives of the property owner or their market status was undetermined.
[1] http://www.sftu.org/rentcontrol.html
[2] http://www.sfrb.org/Modules/ShowDocument.aspx?documentid=188...
http://sfbay.craigslist.org/sfc/apa/
Show me where the rent-controlled units I can get are.
They don't exist, because whatever ones are out there are either crappy enough to more-than-make up for their cheapness, or snapped up by well-connected people.
(Btw, love the URL -- at a glance it reads as stfu, lol.)
data: proportion of renter occupied housing in sf subject to rent control: http://www.thehdmt.org/indicators/view/192 2nd map direct link: http://www.thehdmt.org/img/indicators/pdf/RentControlHousing...
Furthermore, I think you're misunderstanding pricing strategies landlords use to set rent prices. A landlord doesn't (and can't) just say 'oh I need a 4% ROI on my capital, so I need to charge 1200$ of rent for this unit to make up for the 800$ I can charge on the other'. As a landlord, you try to capture as much of the value that consumers are willing to pay for housing as you can. There are various ways of trying that, but all involve variables that are completely separate from the rental income made from other properties (somehow the gambler's fallacy comes to mind, I think both lines of reasoning are in the same class of common cognitive mishaps).
Well I suppose not everyone like fast food workers but in all seriousness there are a bunch of menial jobs in SF that pay 75 - 100k. Usually union protected gigs.
Now it is true that the one-bedroom rent increase probably is blowing away the added after-tax salary. However, if the tech worker lives with roommates (where rents hit ~$1000/month), he will take home more income in the Bay Area than elsewhere.
At a previous startup, a ceo was out drinking beers with some engineers. Now this ceo is quite a nice person, so please don't think that I think poorly of him. Somehow, salaries came up and the ceo mentioned that we were all presumably doing pretty well. Then one of my engineer coworkers mentioned he was paying $2300 or something like that in rent for a small one bedroom near Valencia and 20th, and I said my gf and I were paying $2600 for a medium one bedroom in upper haight. The ceo was utterly shocked at what rent prices were, since he'd moved to the city and bought a house nearly 30 years before. It turns out he was paying something like $1300/mo to live in a mansion in pac heights and his mortgage was almost paid off. The thing that bugged me, in retrospect, was his lack of awareness of one of the primary drivers of engineering salaries: the cost of living in sf. And the impact of the city being actively hostile to tearing down a lot of the pretty crummy housing we have and building up.
edit: not to mention, if you perhaps want to own, $500 - $600K in most of SF is not exactly living in luxury. If you're near real public transport, ie bart, it's a small one bedroom and if you resign yourself to a crappy commute or driving it's a lower end two bedroom, 700-1100 ft^2. Further, you'll pay $1.1k per million dollars of value per month in taxes, so for a $600k house you're giving the city nearly $700/mo for forever.