News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Don't Be Evil, A Chrome extension based on the F... by nostromo on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @01:55AM (#3503772)
Just some honest feedback for the project owners. The logo change (http://i.imgur.com/U8WOI.png) was off-putting for me. You're probably better off if people install this extension out of curiosity and then forget about it entirely. This feels too much like a wink every time you search saying, "hey, some extension is mucking with these results, remember?"
Re:Show HN: Don't Be Evil, A Chrome extension based on the F... by redthrowaway on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @04:01AM (#3504026)
Didn't even notice it until you brought it up.

The biggest issue for me was a massive, "so what?" I installed the extension and did some searches. A few G+ results, nothing else. Okay, I'll search for things I know some of my friends on facebook have talked about lately. Nothing. Alright, I'll search for "deadmau5". Nothing. What's this? 80 personal results? Sure, let's check those. Hey, a twitter link!... to someone I have on G+.

Really not sure what the authors were trying to prove, here. In the end, I got a snarky logo and the same damned results I would have gotten from Google, anyway. Removed.

Note: this is not a failing of the extension's author; I just went back and tried the same searches with the original script and had the same results. No, I didn't Google "movies" as they suggested, and nor has anyone since 1999. When I google "SOPA" without the script, I get a mix of Wikipedia, EFF, and some relevant links from G+. When I repeat the search with the script, I get the same thing and a snarky logo.

Instead of chastising Google for not including results from networks that don't want their social graphs exposed, these "independent engineers" might want to focus on doing social search themselves. Why aren't we complaining that facebook doesn't include G+ in its search results? Might it be because this entire issue is a tempest in a teapot stirred up by companies that wanted to dominate social search, but were beaten to the punch by a company that dominates (surprise, surprise) search?

Re:Show HN: Don't Be Evil, A Chrome extension based on the F... by andrewguenther on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @01:59AM (#3503779)
I definitely agree, but I don't want to shamelessly rip off the original authors of the script. If people want me to do it though, I will consider it. Thanks for your opinion. Maybe as I make my own modifications to the script I will remove it.
Re:Show HN: Don't Be Evil, A Chrome extension based on the F... by andrewguenther on Tuesday January 24, 2012 @09:08PM (#3508044)
Just removed the logo. I will be updating the extension in the Chrome Web Store in a minute.