Re:Why AI Won't Cause Unemployment
by CuriouslyC on Sunday March 05, 2023 @09:27AM
(#35029841)
The luddites were fundamentally selfish. Imagine if workers in a business burned down a competing business so they didn't get laid off during a downturn - zero sympathy right?
Ah yes here selfishness is wrong. Everywhere else in capitalism itβs a sacred virtue.
My sympathy depends on context. In the society I live in, my sympathy would be very limited, as there is a social security system so these people will not go homeless or starve (though the experience will still be painful to them).
In a society where there's no such system, I don't blame them at all. If someone is coming for the roof over your head and the sandwich you eat, it doesn't matter if they're doing it legally or illegally. You can't begrudge someone defending their own existence.
If I really believed that my suffering would lead to a post-scarcity paradise, yes, I would (but I don't believe it). And this rhetoric isn't just from free-marketeers. On the left, that's also what motivated people to endure the insanity of Stalin's and Mao's regimes -- that all the suffering they endured was temporary and was for a higher purpose -- to achieve a utopia that always seemed just out of reach.
No, the Luddites actually lost their livelihoods in the early Industrial Revolution, and they would reap none of the eventual benefits of technological advancement. Their quality of life decreased suddenly and dramatically because they were replaced by technology.
If you'd be told that some technology will make you obsolete and you will become a homeless pauper by next year, but it's ok: decades from now the improved technology will lead humanity towards a post-scarcity paradise; would you be ok with that?