News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Americans need to be richer than ever to buy their first ... by mdasen on Saturday March 04, 2023 @02:04PM (#35023477)
It's complicated. Even what is considered a high-interest loan is a bit complicated. You think you're looking at high-interest loans because a few years ago you saw 3% loans (and you're not wrong that the interest rates are higher and make home buying way less affordable).

The US Government has Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac which in some ways subsidizes the process. They're forced to buy loans even when the market is bad and might be unprofitable as long as the loans conform to their pre-set standards (and no other buyer wants to buy the loan) and they assume a decent amount of risk. It would be hard for a bank to offer a 30-year fixed mortgage at 2.8% without government help. While banks were able to borrow below 2.8% a year or two ago, they aren't able to do that today. In other countries, if your mortgage was 2.8%, you're likely facing a steep increase in your monthly payments now.

Yes, right now if you took out a 30-year fixed mortgage, you'd be facing a higher interest rate than a year or two ago. However, even when rates are higher, there's still government help. During an economic downturn, banks might lack liquidity to make loans, but the US government essentially gives them liquidity to make home loans. If banks are lacking liquidity, loan rates will be higher. Even during good times, the government offering more available funds to lend will offer better terms. If people were competing for a more limited amount of funds, banks could charge more. Because each bank basically has as much liquidity as is demanded, it pushes rates down.

Whether a rate is high is kinda complicated. Is 6% high interest? It certainly feels that way when you're living in a market where first homes go for nearly a million. However, one of the reasons that prices went up so much is that interest rates went so low which allowed people to pay more. Prices can't come down as interest rates go up because owners who sell would then need to buy a new place at the higher interest rate while being potentially underwater on their current loan. It makes more sense for you to remain in your $900,000 condo with a 3% interest rate than to sell it for $800,000 and buy an $800,000 condo at 6%. Selling, you'd have to come up with $100,000 for the bank and then buying the new place (even though the new place is also at a lower price), your monthly payment would be higher because of the higher interest rate.

If you could buy a place for $100,000 at 6% interest, it probably wouldn't feel like a high rate because the monthly payment would be low. Interest rates were above 8% 1975-1990 and didn't drop below 6% until the early 2000s. However, low rates over the past decade has sent the housing market soaring because you can pay $1M instead of $650k if your rate is 3% instead of 7% (and you can afford the down payment). Yea, the monthly payment on the million dollar place is actually lower than the same place at $650k at 7% (assuming 20% down on both).

So yes, there's still government subsidies at work to make loans more affordable, but as loans become more affordable, housing prices rise. If interest rates go up, you're facing a market where sellers can't sell to you without either you paying way more than they did (because of the interest rate) or them losing a bunch of money. In some sense, the big subsidy is to the people who locked in 2.8% loans. Interest rates are up, inflation is happening, and their payments don't change on what is usually the largest cost in most people's lives. What they're paying back is likely going to end up being a lot less because inflation/interest is going to be a good bit higher for most of the term of the loan. However, there are still subsidies at work, but it seems less unlikely that it'll be the super-subsidy of paying back a lot less purchasing power by having a 2.8% loan at a time when interest/inflation is outpacing that.

There are no comments on this comment yet.