The longevity of ICE/hybrid vehicles has long been a bugbear for auto manufacturers. One of the convenient things for them in the push for EVs is that EVs will inherently have less utility at 10 - 15 years than ICE vehicles.
With manufacturers' standard EV warranty including 70% bat capacity at 10 years or XYZ miles, it's almost like an ICE manufacturer saying your gas tank will get 30% smaller after a decade. Except that an aging battery also has reduced current draw and thermal allowances, so there is also less instantaneous power available as the battery pack ages.
This is an engineering reality of battery EVs, to keep them safe as their packs age. The power limit could be viewed as consistent with older ICE's not performing at nameplate HP, which none of them will without significant maintenance.
But this is why I'm cynical about automakers and EVs: EVs lower their cost burden in the medium to long term with simplified production, and "enhanced" planned obsolence via wear components that are much more expensive and can significantly limit the utility of the vehicle in the 10 - 20 year time horizon, as compared to ICEs and maybe hybrids.
They can already do that - they arguably are already doing that - by making combustion engines which aren't reliable in the long term. And there are so many other things that you can design to be unreliable in the long term, especially in modern cars which have lots of features.
They're warrantied at 70% for 10 years because that's the minimum the law requires. We could see manufacturers put a better warranty on their vehicles as a selling point.
I haven't done much research into this, but I believe the existing EVs from various manufacturers have had very good battery degradation characteristics over time and over mileage. Not anything like 70% over 10 years. If you look at technical documents and presentations that manufacturers create for industry trade shows, training their technicians, and in press releases for new models, they seem to genuinely care about battery degradation and mention all the things they're doing to ensure a long battery life. Obviously the situation might change in the future and companies may decide to become greedy, but for now this doesn't appear to be an issue. And as battery technology (& capacity) advances over time, this is going to be less of a problem in the future.
Who? Which engines are not reliable over 5/7/10+ years? Fiat? Some custom thing built in a German garage? All the big manufacturers are churning out amazingly reliable IC engines. Almost anything from Honda/Toyota/BMW/Merc will last decades. Maybe some sensor needs replacing or an electrical circuit has an issue, but with normal maintenance modern IC engines go forever, far longer than most new car buyer ever keeps the vehicle. The air conditioning, cruise control, radio, suspension, transmission and seat cushions will all be dead long before the engine gives up the ghost.
What breaks are things like sensors and control systems, little inexpensive parts that are generally worthless compared to the effort needed to diagnose and replace them. And that isn't going away with EVs. They have basically the same number of drivetrain sensors and systems as any IC car. Taking the car into the mechanic because of an engine light will still be a thing.
I think the answer is competition, and I don't see why there should be less competition for BEVs which are simpler to construct than ICE cars.
Additionally, some managers claim that real-world battery life is much longer than expected, see https://www.forbes.com/sites/carltonreid/2022/08/01/electric...
Also graphite is diamagnetic, so strong magnets actually push it away.
Also, although I don't have the numbers for your issue about strong magnets pushing it away, I've found you need REALLY strong B Fields to do this. In other words, are we sure this is an effect that is at play here? (I'm asking)
A car's motor is in the elements, and gets bumped around and otherwise has to keep working in a non-optimal environment.
I'd say if motor survives 15 years, that's plenty, as the kinds of folks who buy BMWs tend to buy new at least every 10 years, I suspect.
The OTHER thing people I think are missing in this discussion is: how much OTHER car tech is going to improve over, say, that 15 year time? Advanced driver safety tech alone may make buying a new car a wise choice, vs servicing an older, less-tech-capable vehicle, for certain market segments.
> We asked BMW about the life expectancy of those brushes and commutators, and what happens to the dust as they wear. While they couldn't give us a lifetime estimate for the brushes, they did reassure us that the brush modules are "in an enclosed and sealed compartment, eliminating dust contamination inside the stator/rotor wiring." Anyone who has worked with brakes or even brushed DC motors knows just how fine those dust particles are. It will be interesting to see both how long they last and just how much dust those modules will actually contain (or release).