Re:The moral case against equity language
by throwbadubadu on Friday March 03, 2023 @12:37AM
(#35006212)
Close to a disability, I don't give a shit, and reading that I don't even understand til now what is better, for what reason... disability first, person first, what first, wtf?? Can we just communicate?
> can give birth, it is sub-optimal and exclusionary as a generic term for a person giving, or who has given, birth
Realize that smartassing someone with that excourse is alienating andor insulting andor exclusionary to other people the same, for whatever reason, may it be a different level of education or just disagreement.
> the mission was broader
It is good that you call it like that what it is, a mission for the new missionaries, almost just a religion of a strange minority that usually even is not affected at all. Please also try to understand a little the other side.
“enslaved people” is not people/person-first language.
“People who are enslaved” is people-first language.
“enslaved people” is “situation first” (more commonly “identity first” or “disability first”, but neither strictly applies to “being enslaved”) language, just as “slaves” is. (In the disability context, “the disabled” and “disabled people” are textbook examples of “disability first” language, to which “people first” or “person first” language is contrasted.)
EDIT: Yes, I realize that this is an example of "people-first" language given near the opening of this opinion piece. It says something that in this rant about "equity language", the example given of the application of a particular form ("people-first language") of equity language is basically a textbook example of what that form seeks to avoid rather than what it prescribes.
> For example, it seems like we can’t say “mother” anymore in medical settings.
You can absolutely use “mother” to describe a specific person who, in fact, is a mother in medical settings. Because people of non-feminine gender identity can give birth, it is sub-optimal and exclusionary as a generic term for a person giving, or who has given, birth.
> I support trans people living however they want, but my mother was a mother
Literally no one has a problem with your mother being described as a mother.
> At work, a “women in engineering” group got renamed to something bland like “gender minorities in tech”.
Presumably, it got renamed that because whoever made decisions for it decided the mission was broader than women. “Gender minorities” isn’t a bland alternative to “women”, it has a broader scope.