Anyway, “fetal nutrient pod” avoids a few other bad issues with “pregnant person”. For instance, corporations and perhaps buildings and geographic features are legally people, but humans that have no rights are not:
Is there an article or paper about this somewhere? I searched for it and can't find anything.
That is fake news from a convicted fraudster. It was claimed but never supported by evidence [0].
"Fertility clinician Cecil Jacobson claimed to have transplanted a fertilized egg from a female baboon to the omentum in the abdominal cavity of a male baboon in the mid-1960s, which then carried the fetus for four months; however, Jacobson did not publish his claims in a scientific journal, and was subsequently convicted on several unrelated counts of fraud for ethical misconduct."
I didn't.
As Cyphase said [0], I posted the non-mobile link which many people -- including myself -- appreciate.
I'd question the association between mother and woman, rather than mother and birth
It’s the same with people who menstruate — not only for trans men but for post menopausal women, women who’ve had hysterectomies, or are otherwise have amenorrhea.
Particularly when that language control is transparently used for power seeking.
We don’t need to shape every utterance around outliers — that’s pathological and stifles discussion.
Normal people instinctively understand this, and “woman” and “mother” are completely understandable and useful terms, even if there are a handful of exceptions out of millions are exceptions to the strict definition.
If they are successful in have a pregnant trans-woman in Unicode, you just know that, depending on the depiction, it will be used as "The fat guy"-icon.
I don't see the problem of including small groups - they are the ones who are most invisible and marginalized and therefore in need of recognition. You say it makes little sense, but to me it not only makes sense but is self-evident. Even if you're right, I can scroll through my emoji map and see many that are even more niche, yet none of them receive the angry flak GNC emoji do.
1. "I don't believe being trans is a thing"
2. "Consequently, I'll reject statements predicated upon transness being a real thing"
3. "Consequently, I believe 'gender' and 'sex' are the same thing"
Otherwise, your statement is incorrect because trans men exist and they can get pregnant.
Trans men are female and have a uterus and ovaries and a vagina.
If they get surgery to remove those things or even get on hormone therapy, it's unlikely for a trans man to get pregnant, but otherwise a trans man can get pregnant. One would say "that's a pregnant man", with "man" being a superset of {"cis man", "trans man"}, as it would be a superset of {"white man", "black man"}. In fact, you could refer to a "pregnant man" as "a man" since "man" is a superset of {"cis man", "trans man", "white man", "black man", "pregnant man", ...}.
But I wish people would get to the heart of the argument ("I don't believe being trans is a thing") than hint at it with proxy slogans like this to score rhetorical points. If nothing else, it's more easily falsifiable; for example, most psychologists would disagree with the statement "being trans is not a real thing".
Should everyone take care to account for the most improbable interpretations, even unintended ones? Thanks for providing a good sample of equity language. Feels like being dictated by an elite to the masses.
So that’s an edge case. They can call themselves a mother or father or birthing person or pink elephant. That shouldn’t mean someone else can’t identify as a mother or father or whatnot.
This isn’t even a novel delineation; adoption and surrogacy have long dealt with the separation of parenting and reproductive roles. Besides, history’s foremost feminists would cringe at womanhood and motherhood being reduced to a biological function.
"A pregnant person is a woman" doesn't say anything about what people are allowed to call themselves, but rather makes an absolute statement that all pregnant people can be called "women". It doesn't take into account the edge cases you mentioned, and that's what shrimp_emoji took offense to.