No, I do not typically profit from piracy. When I purchase a kids' movie on DVD, Hollywood says that I have only purchased a "licence" to use the movie. When I then rip the movie to avi's (no complex decoding required to view) and copy the files to two old laptops so that my kids can watch the movie in the car, Hollywood says that I am a pirate -- that I am stealing their movie.
Not only does this process cost me time (and thus money) and aggravation, I also get the benefit of being labelled a criminal. At least the kids are happy.
http://paulgraham.com/wealth.html
I don't think anyone realistically considers format shifting as copyright infringement, other than opportunistic executives. I'm not aware of anyone being taken to court for format shifting.
Oh, and I'm not sure if your 'profitable discussion' pun was intentional or not, but I enjoyed it anyway.
Hollywood has also fought to force other countries to outlaw fair use. Here's an example:
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2011/05/us-in-2005-l...
So yes, it is quite clear that Hollywood considers ripping a DVD to be criminal activity.
What about someone decompiling someone else's app and putting it up for sale on the Android market. Is that wrong?
What about hacking into someone's server and copying their source code and design documents and using it to build a rival service?
What about selling software which contains GPL code and not acknowledging it or providing the source code?