Re:The moral case against equity language
by roughly on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:49PM
(#35000944)
Alternatively, there’s a theory of change at play here that follows a relatively long path of inquiry through politics, sociology, and neuroscience to identify in-group/out-group dynamics and mental shortcuts as central blockers to attempts to increase cross-group empathy and drive social change.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The moral case against equity language
by scarmig on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:38PM
(#35001703)
I don't dispute that there's a theory of change here: "if we explore the linguistic landscape, we can discover a set of signifiers that will help us to destroy racism/sexism/etc."
I just reject that. We don't live in a Harry Potter book where the correct series of incantations affect the material world.
Re:The moral case against equity language
by roughly on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:57PM
(#35001970)
That's not the theory of change at play here. You're rejecting a straw man.
As to the rest of it: "Officer, arrest that man" is a series of incantations that affect the material world.
Re:The moral case against equity language
by scarmig on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:06PM
(#35002070)
I can say that right now, and nothing happens. The words aren't the causal elements here changing the world; it's the referants and power hierarchies that do.
The proper analogy would be thinking that requiring saying "Officer, detain-in-an-official-capacity that man!" instead would somehow fix police violence.
Re:The moral case against equity language
by roughly on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:08PM
(#35002098)
> I can say that right now, and nothing happens. The words aren't the causal elements here changing the world; it's the referants and power hierarchies that do.
And you think this is something that’s not understood among those pushing for linguistics changes?
I think that.
I think those people distract and soothe themselves from their inability to enact change with linguistic games.
Re:The moral case against equity language
by stillkicking on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:58PM
(#35001092)
Even if that were true, I'd still not put any faith in the empathy skills of people who use e.g. "incel" as a slur, who claim "it's okay to be white" is hate speech and who call arson, vandalism and looting "mostly peaceful protests" because the in-group did it.
Re:The moral case against equity language
by roughly on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:01PM
(#35001149)
So long as you're not reducing entire groups into caricatures of themselves, it's probably fine.
Re:The moral case against equity language
by stillkicking on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:07PM
(#35001219)
It's not a caricature if it's taught at supposedly elite institutions of education, into which admission is contingent on a declaration of adherence to said ways of thinking.