News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by mindvirus on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @11:39PM (#34992076)
It feels like simple regulation could just be:

- non-competes must be paid at the max of your past 3 years earnings, including benefits.

- minimum $100k/year.

- maximum 12 months.

Assuming companies need to enforce them, they'll have a mechanism to (this is similar to what hedge funds do).

Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by KRAKRISMOTT on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @11:43PM (#34992101)
- tied to inflation
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by wahnfrieden on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @11:58PM (#34992194)
why advocate for allowing them? what's in it for workers?
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by imgabe on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:04AM (#34992216)
fully paid vacation for as long as the company wants to enforce the non-compete? Or you get another job and get free double salary while working in a completely unrelated industry?

I think the parent comment was pretty clear that what's in it for workers is a bunch of money.

Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by terminalcommand on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:32AM (#34992344)
Fully paid vacation is sometimes called garden-leave. In my country, you have to pay some salary during non-compete but it is nowhere near your full salary (1/10th in most cases).
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by fbdab103 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:51AM (#34992468)
1/10 of a salary for all but the upper echelon of worker compensation does not seem sufficient to put food on the table.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by terminalcommand on Friday March 10, 2023 @03:37AM (#35092020)
Normally high earning employees have non-compete clauses that are enforced.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by whamlastxmas on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:33AM (#34992352)
Having to take two years of time off of work can be really detrimental to some careers in some fields.

For as much as capitalists love free markets, they really hate the idea of employees selling their labor in a free market.

Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by imgabe on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:36AM (#34992373)
That's why you get paid, to compensate you for the detriment.

Employees should have the option to refuse the payment and go ahead and compete. Then it would be up to employers to make sure the offer is attractive enough that employees would want to take it. That's how a free market works.

Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by burnished on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:43AM (#34992425)
You dont need non competes in order to do as you propose here though
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by whamlastxmas on Friday March 03, 2023 @06:23PM (#35016363)
> Employees should have the option to refuse the payment and go ahead and compete.

Absolutely! But in reality NCs are mandatory parts of accepting employment to begin with, and it's a very broken power dynamic because I need this $150k job a hell of a lot more than my employer needs me as one additional person.

Additionally, a non-compete that only matches your existing salary isn't enough. There is a super strong compounding effect of

1. You haven't worked for two years, your value going back into the labor market could be much lower

2. Your income could have grown tremendously in those two years instead of forced to be the same

3. The net effect between 1 and 2 means you're not just behind the effect of 1 on its own, you're now actually super far behind

4. You now have two fewer years of your working life for your salary to compound

5. The savings you could have made in those years at a higher income level also aren't compounded as they would have been in your investment portfolio

Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by hackitup7 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:03AM (#34992211)
There are some jobs (for example as referenced elsewhere hedge funds) where employees have knowledge that could be directly damaging to their former employer if it were taken to a competitor.

For example, other Fund X has a huge short position in a company. The way that finance solves this is by paying employees to stay unemployed (and not take their potentially damaging information elsewhere).

There isn't really anything directly "in it" for workers, so paying them out for their time seems reasonable.

Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by Larrikin on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:06AM (#34992220)
So why not make it generally illegal except in very specific circumstances?
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by pnpnp on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:40AM (#34992401)
Or how about allow for knowledge of one firm being shared with the other being illegal since it’s proprietary (I think this is probably already the case).
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by phibz on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:03AM (#34992551)
That's very hard to police and prove. It's easier if you pay them to be unemployed for long enough for their knowledge to be less valuable. This is very common with businesses like hedge funds. But I agree non-compete should be narrowly allowed and only in situations like this that are more equitable.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by eftychis on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:02AM (#34992205)
Yeah I agree. Why even allow them at all?
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by bmitc on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:14AM (#34992264)
I think allowing them but forcing companies to pay is a way to make them put their money where their mouth is. While I think removing them is good, removing them completely gives the opposing crowd something to yell about. If you allow them but then say, well you gotta pay to get the benefit, I think we'd quickly see them drop off, the proponents of non-competes would have little to no argument, and companies who really think they need them can just pay for them if they're so valuable to their business strategy.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by a_techwriter_00 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:06AM (#34992566)
If history's any indication, you can't give companies an inch. They'll take advantage of employee ignorance of the law, or do shady things with the payments under the logic that if the employee sues them for the money they can tie the case up in the legal system until they give up, or whatever other chicanery they can imagine to squirm out of having to pay.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by surfsvammel on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:07AM (#34992228)
Similar to what other countries do as well.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by asah on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:09AM (#34992241)
This hurts our economy, since we're not utilizing scarce talent.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by ISL on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:22AM (#34992294)
There are a lot of productive things one can do on garden leave. The only thing you can't do is the thing you were doing before.

Continuing education, charity work, spending time with family, work in a non-competing field, etc.

Working one job but getting paid for two ain't that bad, as long as it is at the rate specified by the grandparent post.

Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by asah on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:43PM (#34999922)
This comment paints a bike shed: non-competes affect some of the scarcest talent in the world, in the prime of their careers.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by Mizoguchi on Thursday March 02, 2023 @12:32AM (#34992346)
Skills + experience is the only way most people can put food on the table. That's a basic human right and should be non negotiable. If companies are too afraid of loosing their trade secrets that's what IP, NDAs and patents are for. I rejected offers after months of negotiations because of these bs poorly drafted and ridiculously broad non compete agreements. Many companies, particularly startups, don't even understand why they have them as it is usually the lawyers for the investors who draft them.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by bagels on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:00AM (#34992531)
Should be 2x or 3x as much. People change jobs to increase wages, this would still suppress wages and productivity.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by runtu on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:10AM (#34992584)
This is pretty much what was implemented in Finland starting last year.

If an employer wants to keep a non-compete clause in a contract, they are forced to pay their prior salary for the agreed period (max 12 months) after employment - regardless of where the employee chooses to work afterwards. If they go to a non-competitor, they can start immediately and get their new salary on top of the non-compete compensation.

Needless to say, nearly all non-compete clauses were systematically removed from existing employment contracts.

Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by paxys on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:17AM (#34992626)
I disagree. At most, we should allow it in limited circumstances where it would be on the company to prove why the non-compete is absolutely necessary. High tech chip manufacturing where the employee has a wealth of trade secrets in their head and taking it to a competitor would be disastrous – maybe. Reading a script at a call center or making a sandwich – hell no.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by mindvirus on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:06PM (#35000236)
That's where I'd push back. If Subway is willing to pay someone $100k to not make sandwiches at a competitor, why stop them?
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by paxys on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:25PM (#35002299)
Because the person should still have a choice as to whether they want to accept the $100k or not.
Re:FTC has proposed banning non-compete agreements by mindvirus on Thursday March 02, 2023 @09:47PM (#35005195)
In this hypothetical, they'd also have the choice not to work at Subway in the first place. But realistically, very few companies (especially fast food restaurants) would want a non-compete if they had to pay for it.

My broader point is that if we say that there may be places that a non compete makes sense, we can both allow that and give workers protections - especially workers with the least leverage to negotiate.