News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Cannot Have Exactly-Once Delivery by iainmerrick on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @06:39PM (#34989944)
Thinking about it, we’re probably violently agreeing with just some differences in terminology.

I’m arguing that exactly-once delivery is possible if the message receipt happens in a single place, but maybe others don’t see that as a distributed system at all.

Potentially messy. Now you have two distributed system messages - the initial notification and the ack.

Not a problem, both are idempotent! :)

Re:You Cannot Have Exactly-Once Delivery by Kalium on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:29AM (#35011692)
> I’m arguing that exactly-once delivery is possible if the message receipt happens in a single place, but maybe others don’t see that as a distributed system at all.

I think that only holds if the sender is also in the same place. Otherwise there's the very real chance of a message getting lost, turning your system from exactly-once into at-most-once. At this point your sender, consumer, and messaging systems are one system, so it's probably reasonable to question if that's a distributed system.