News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twilight of the Libraries: What Gets Lost When Books Go O... by JohnFen on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @05:05PM (#34989007)
Well, I'm hardly alone in my preferences, but my point was to answer the question "what is being lost". I gave two examples of real things that are being lost.

That loss may or may not be economically required -- but it's still a loss either way.

> It's always going to be cheaper for a library to lend internet/devices for reading

The economics of this may differ depending on where you are, but I'm 99% sure that this isn't the case where I am.

Re:Twilight of the Libraries: What Gets Lost When Books Go O... by crazygringo on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @05:41PM (#34989357)
Virtually everwhere has cheap enough mobile data in 2023 to read books with, so internet is not an issue.

And I think you may be severly underestimating the cost of maintaining library-sized collections of books, in labor and utilities and maintenance and real estate. Consumer digital devices, especially things like e-ink readers, cost almost nothing compared to that.

Re:Twilight of the Libraries: What Gets Lost When Books Go O... by JohnFen on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @06:02PM (#34989563)
> Virtually everwhere has cheap enough mobile data in 2023 to read books with, so internet is not an issue.

The expense wouldn't be in the communications. It would be in replacing the broken devices. And with the program I'm familiar with, there was no communications involved anyway. You get the ebook preloaded on the device.

> I think you may be severly underestimating the cost of maintaining library-sized collections of books, in labor and utilities and maintenance and real estate.

I'm very familiar with these costs in the library system where I live, and I am privy to the figures it was looking at when developing their own ebook program.

I know they vary a lot depending on where you are, though, so it wouldn't surprise me at all to learn that there are areas where it pencils out very differently.

However, as I've said, even if the ebook program saved big money, something important is still lost without physical books.