Re:Blindly submitting content to HN, good or bad?
by chc on Sunday January 22, 2012 @06:54PM
(#3498316)
This would seem to imply that comments are somehow "superior" to stories, and I'm not sure that's supposed to be the case.
Re:Blindly submitting content to HN, good or bad?
by nantes on Monday January 23, 2012 @12:37AM
(#3499243)
I get what you're saying, but I am not sure it does.
When I first arrived on HN, I was unsure about what was appropriate to post. I learned by reading the comments and contributing where I had something useful to share.
Now, after a year or two, I often hear or read a story and think HN has to see this. Then I step back and really weigh whether it fits HN or if I just think it's cool. Often, I end up not submitting. By starting out slow I realized HN isn't popularity contest, but an important community.
That was my experience anyway, YMMV.
For instance, users won't get karma points for stories they submit until they reach some threshold for karma from their comments. This would be beneficial in a number of ways: