News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 15% Tax Rate by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 22, 2012 @10:52AM (#3496786)
Fred Wilson chooses non representative numbers to make his point: But there is a bigger issue here and that is whether it is good policy for someone of Mitt Romney's or my wealth to pay a lower tax rate than the average hard working american citizen.

Mitt Romney and Fred Wilson are atypical cases.

The bottom quintile pays 4.3% of income in tax, assuming they have any income. The middle quintile pays 14.2%, the nation as a whole pays 20.7%, and the top quintile pays 25.8%. The top 1% pays 31.2% [1].

The difference between the CBO and Fred Wilson's analysis is corporate income taxes.

Suppose Fred Wilson buys 1 share of twitter worth $100. Twitter then makes $10 of profits, which it does not distributed as dividends [2]. This is taxed at the rate of 15-35%, so twitters balance sheet expands by $8.5/share, i.e. Fred Wilson's 1 share is now worth $108.5. He then sells, and pays 15% cap gains, earning back $107.22. To me that looks like a 27.8% tax rate.

So yeah, go ahead and tax cap gains at individual income rates. But eliminate the corporate income tax while you are at it.

[1] http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/100xx/doc10068/effective_tax_rate...

http://www.cbo.gov/publications/collections/tax/2010/graphic... (Graphs are for 2007 data, not 2006 data. Not much difference though.)

[2] Dividends are taxed at individual income tax rates, except sometimes.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by Retric on Sunday January 22, 2012 @01:15PM (#3497191)
Your ignoring 1/2 of Social Security and Medicare taxes. And also not plotting the tax rate of the top 1% or 0.1% both of which are dramatically lower due to not paying Social Security on income over 120k or Medicare on investment income.

The bottom quintile pays over 20% if they have a job. Medicare alone is 15.3%.

Also, corporate income taxes only apply to US investments, which is rarely 100% of any sane persons investments. To top that off if you actually buy stock from a large company their tax rate is often below 5%.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by orangecat on Sunday January 22, 2012 @01:57PM (#3497315)
Your ignoring 1/2 of Social Security and Medicare taxes.

Well, defenders of the current SS and Medicare system keep insisting that they're not really taxes, they're "contributions" for "insurance" that everybody pays into for the purpose of receiving benefits later. I'm all for abolishing those taxes and funding means-testing benefits out of general revenues, but the left hates that idea because they don't want SS and Medicare to be thought of as welfare.

The bottom quintile pays over 20% if they have a job. Medicare alone is 15.3%.

That's Social Security, Medicare is only a few percent. But the rate is correct; "your employer pays half" is a legal fiction.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by anamax on Sunday January 22, 2012 @04:38PM (#3497781)
> Well, defenders of the current SS and Medicare system keep insisting that they're not really taxes, they're "contributions" for "insurance" that everybody pays into for the purpose of receiving benefits later.

Note that the benefits payouts are incredibly progressive. Folks who don't put much money into SS get a much better return on their money than folks who "contribute" the max each year.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by Retric on Sunday January 22, 2012 @06:52PM (#3498305)
Except married people receive dramatically better benefits than single people.
Re:The 15% Tax Rate by anamax on Sunday January 22, 2012 @11:01PM (#3498962)
> Except married people receive dramatically better benefits than single people.

"better benefits" depends on their income distribution. There are folks who don't marry because that would result in smaller social security benefits.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by Retric on Sunday January 22, 2012 @11:41PM (#3499080)
It's true that the benefits from marriage A can decrease after marriage B. But, they are still higher than if everyone had been single the whole time.

AKA the only time where X and Y getting married lowers their combined benefits if X or Y was married to someone else z before this and where receiving marriage benefits from this.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by anamax on Monday January 23, 2012 @08:51AM (#3500304)
I'm pretty sure that my wife and I reduced our (future) SS benefits by getting married, and neither of us have been married before. (We definitely increased our income taxes significantly - welcome to AMT.)

We both have decent incomes, so there's no "he'd have benefited from the low-income subsidy".

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by Retric on Monday January 23, 2012 @06:00PM (#3502590)
No, it does not work like that. The math on benefits are really simple you can take either your SS benefit or 50% of your living spouses or 100% of your dead spouses. Taking 50% of your spouses is a proxy for the 'low-income' subsidy where a single worker is supporting 2 people. There is a minor 'penalty' for taking SS early which is supposed to even out the expected benefit but this is calculated for each benefit separately.

So, let's say you decide to retire at 62 and not wait till 68. You have 2 choices you can take your normal befit and gain nothing, or you can take your 50% your spouses benefit at 62 wait until 68 take your benefit calculated as if you had revived zero benefits. Net result your ahead.

PS: Feel free to use there calculators to check this out: http://www.ssa.gov/planners/benefitcalculators.htm

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 22, 2012 @06:01PM (#3498111)
False. Did you even read my link? "Social insurance, or payroll, taxes are attributed to households paying those taxes directly or paying them indirectly through their employers"

The bottom quintile also receives things like EITC, which dramatically reduce their taxes.

It's true that US corporate income taxes apply to US investments. Similarly, Irish income tax applies to Irish investments, Japanese income tax to Japanese investments, etc. So what?

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by Retric on Sunday January 22, 2012 @06:10PM (#3498160)
http://www.cbo.gov/publications/collections/tax/2010/graphic...

Page 2, Social Insurance Taxes is ~8% on that graph.

Also, the bottom quartile includes people that don't work. I specifically said those in the bottom quartile who do.

As to non US companies paying non US taxes, there is no universal corporate tax rate. You can't assume that non US companies are going to be paying US style income taxes.

As to promoting investment. Getting a Masters is a huge investment in time and money but I don't get to tax my extra earnings at 15% or use pretax money to pay for it etc.

PS: Not that corporate income tax really falls on the owners of a company. You could just as easily say it's the workers that end up paying corporate income tax as it reduces the value of their output work which reduces their income.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 22, 2012 @07:01PM (#3498349)
Assuming you are right about social insurance, that means the lowest quintile pays 12.8% of income in taxes and the top 1% pays 32.8%.

You can't assume that non US companies are going to be paying US style income taxes.

True. For example, a company based in Gurgaon pays fairly little in taxes. On the other hand, they need to provide their own roads, water and police services. (This is partly why Gurgaon is thriving - corporations seem to do a much better job of this than the Indian government.)

You might be right that some nations provide a better benefit/tax ratio. But the solution is not for the US to tax their corporations, the solution is for the US to provide more cost effective government services.

I agree that we should equalize taxes across income sources. My simple proposal? We should eliminate all corporate income taxes, dividend taxes, cap gains, etc, and put all income into the same bucket. But this is unpopular since it makes it more difficult to raise taxes - individuals immediately see higher taxes and blame politicians, rather than merely seeing their jobs go overseas and blame investors, or seeing prices rise and blaming walmart.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by cluda01 on Sunday January 22, 2012 @11:15AM (#3496854)
This is interesting but the problem that I see with this argument is that you are ignoring transfer pricing agreements. Basically companies like Twitter (and google, facebook, etc.) use a bunch of complex tax structures in different countries to legally avoid paying corporate income tax. Google paid something like a 2.6% effective tax rate. Others like GE paid a negative percentage.

So the issue here is that in the case of google or any major tech company investors + company only pay the 15% + marginal effective rate of 1 or 2% which is only 17%.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 22, 2012 @11:29AM (#3496893)
...Twitter (and google, facebook, etc.) use a bunch of complex tax structures in different countries to legally avoid paying corporate income tax.

Yes, many companies use complex tax structures to avoid paying US corporate income taxes on non-US profits. So what? They don't consume any US government services either, and Fred Wilson paid appropriate taxes to whatever nation Twitter Europe lives in.

Similarly, my employees (all located here in India) don't pay any US income taxes. Is there some reason they should?

GE paid a negative percentage of taxes because they lost money in prior years and used a loss carryforward.

The loss carryforward is a necessary hack to the system to prevent taxation from penalizing businesses with volatile income streams. Consider two investments - one makes $10 with P=1. Another makes +$60 with P=0.5, $-40 with $P=0.5. Without the loss carryforward, the volatile company would pay an average tax rate of 45% (15% of $60 when they make money, 0% of -$40 when they lose money).

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by cluda01 on Sunday January 22, 2012 @12:30PM (#3497069)
>They don't consume any US government services either

These sorts of arguments always bother me because they over simplify the complexities of how one benefits from a public good or service. One example would be that Google doesn't have to worry about their engineers getting into a car crash on the way to work because the governments (federal and state) collectively spend billions of dollars ensuring that our roadways are safe for vehicles.

Another example would be that google doesn't have to spend money hiring private militaries or police forces to enforce their contracts because we have a judicial system that is paid for by the tax payers. This particular example is where your "consumption" argument falls down rather directly. Although it's true that they hire their own counsel, they are not the ones paying the salaries of all the various court officials. They "consume" these resources but in many peoples minds, myself included, do not pay their fair share.

>Similarly, my employees (all located here in India) don't pay any US income taxes. Is there some reason they should?

Of course not. The company that you set up and domiciled in America pays income taxes on the profit that you generate. Profit is usually defined as revenue minus expenses. Taxes paid in other countries are considered expenses and as such are accounted for.

>The loss carryforward is a necessary hack to the system to prevent taxation from penalizing businesses with volatile income streams.

Although we can both agree that GE's tax situation is very complex the problems that I and others have is that they directly lobby the government to get these tax incentives. The example I am thinking of is their lobbying arm advocating for an increased depreciation schedule on some of their capital equipment. This isn't fair.

The summary of my problem with your argument is that you benefit from all the things that America provides (government services, easy access to higher education, educated working class, pro-business climate, etc) but don't think that you should have to pay for any of this because "you didn't consume it." Just by living in America and being able to take advantage of these things you have consumed these things and you should have to pay your fair share. Consumption doesn't necessarily mean somebody handing you a check or waiting in a welfare line.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 22, 2012 @06:18PM (#3498183)
One example would be that Google doesn't have to worry about their engineers getting into a car crash on the way to work because the governments (federal and state) collectively spend billions of dollars ensuring that our roadways are safe for vehicles.

This applies only to Google USA. Google USA pays US income tax. Google India does not pay US income tax and does not receive these benefits.

The summary of my problem with your argument is that you benefit from all the things that America provides (government services, easy access to higher education, educated working class, pro-business climate, etc) but don't think that you should have to pay for any of this because "you didn't consume it."

My employees were educated mostly here: http://www.nifdpune.co.in/ and here http://www.softpune.com/index.shtml. I didn't ask where my devs went to school, but it was probably an IIT. Explain again how I'm consuming US government services?

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by thurn on Sunday January 22, 2012 @03:20PM (#3497561)
Obviously Google Inc. consumes US government services. The point is that Google Ireland Inc. probably doesn't. Google Inc. pays its fair share of U.S. corporate tax on domestic revenue, and Google Ireland pays tax in Ireland. Why should Google Ireland's revenue, which never comes into America, be subject to U.S. tax law? They don't rely on U.S. government services, they rely on Irish government services.
Re:The 15% Tax Rate by cluda01 on Sunday January 22, 2012 @03:44PM (#3497616)
Because they are waiting for a tax holiday so that they can repatriate the profit without paying taxes on it.
Re:The 15% Tax Rate by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 22, 2012 @06:23PM (#3498197)
Yes, Google Ireland is choosing not to invest money in the USA because of the hostile business environment in the US. So what? Is Google Ireland somehow obligated to do business in the US in an effort to pay more US taxes?

Is the Guinness Brewing Company or Tata similarly obligated to do business in the US just so the US government can tax them? And on the flip side, is GM obligated to do business in India so that India can tax them?

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by cluda01 on Monday January 23, 2012 @01:29PM (#3501467)
The shareholders of Google own stakes in Google, Inc. which is an American company not Google Ireland. Google Ireland is a subsidiary of Google, Inc. Ultimately the end goal of Google, Inc. is to maximize profit for shareholders. To pretend that Google Ireland is some independent company company that makes its own decisions where to do business isn't particularly prescient in my opinion.

Given the billions of dollars that is building up in parking spaces overseas for major tech companies such as Google indicates to me here that the motivation isn't to re-invest in business overseas but to wait patiently for a tax holiday and repatriate the capital at next to tax free. And this is what I disagree with.

We can come up with all sorts of points and counter points about why our particular positions are correct but my issue is as follows:

1. I suppose that Google has built all these complicated transfer pricing agreements so that they can accumulate capital with out being taxed and wait for a tax holiday to repatriate the capital at next to no cost.

If 1 is true then I believe that this is wrong and Google is not paying their fair share.

Which part of this do you disagree with?

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by yummyfajitas on Monday January 23, 2012 @09:43PM (#3503218)
You are making the implicit assumption (2) that Google's "fair share" includes some fraction of the money they make outside the US.

I disagree - I believe taxes are payment for government services received. Google Ireland and the Guinness Brewing Company did not receive government services from the US, and hence their "fair share" (to the US) is precisely $0.

Incidentally, the shareholders of Google USA may not live in the US. And similarly, the shareholders of Guinness may be located in the US. If it turns out that some large fraction of Guinness shareholders live in the US, should Guinness start paying taxes in the US for it's Irish operations?

(Guinness does, of course, pay taxes in the US for profits made by it's US subsidiary.)

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by p_alexander on Thursday January 26, 2012 @02:49PM (#3515640)
When Google transfers its IP that was created in the US to an overseas company "headquartered" in the Bahamas so that their subsidiary in Google Ireland can license the IP and not pay money to Google US, thereby avoiding US taxes, then Google Ireland certainly received benefit from the US government. This holds up so long as you believe that Google receives government benefit from US laws, regulations, and infrastructure, which I think they certainly do.

So it's not so much about forcing truly international companies to pay taxes in the US (though they should pay taxes if they are indeed subsidiaries making money from the work of a parent company when that parent company repatriates profits), it's more about exposing the legal-by-letter-but-not-by-spirit practices of companies that hide money generated in the US overseas.

See http://www.npr.org/2011/03/17/134619750/how-offshore-tax-hav...

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by thurn on Sunday January 22, 2012 @03:58PM (#3497663)
Yes, that was a pretty dumb precedent for Bush to set.
Re:The 15% Tax Rate by anamax on Sunday January 22, 2012 @04:44PM (#3497796)
You still haven't explained why Google should pay US taxes on Google Ireland's profits. Those profits were made using Ireland's infrastructure and were taxed there.
Re:The 15% Tax Rate by anamax on Sunday January 22, 2012 @04:47PM (#3497809)
> the governments (federal and state) collectively spend billions of dollars ensuring that our roadways are safe for vehicles.

Where do you think that "the governments" got that money?

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by onenine on Sunday January 22, 2012 @11:50AM (#3496957)
http://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2010/01/135105.htm

Google, and of course virtually every multi-national corporation based in the US, does make use of many US government capabilities. I don't think it makes any sense to say:

>They don't consume any US government services either

However, I do think the corporate income tax issue is a subtle one.

It'd be interesting to compare what Larry and Sergey will pay in taxes versus government outlays for the things that have made Google possible.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by shareme on Sunday January 22, 2012 @11:36AM (#3496913)
Yes, but lets say w talk about the $5 million dollar company..if we have no US corp taxes than that company can locate in the USA and save possibly $500,000 in corp taxes.

We might get enough offsets in jobs, payroll taxes, etc to offset the corp taxes lost.

And better yet it does skew certain manufacturing concerns to not out-source but in-source..

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by gwillen on Sunday January 22, 2012 @11:09AM (#3496838)
Re:The 15% Tax Rate by dexen on Sunday January 22, 2012 @11:27AM (#3496887)
The comic, however snarky and cute, manages only to obscure the point further. The (E) [in the comic] is different than other ones, because there's no exchange of goods nor services for the money between the company and its owner, the Shareholder.

Let me put it my way:

When a plumber puts his knowledge and tools to work, his revenue is taxed once, at personal level.

When a shareholder puts his knowledge and money to work (along with other shareholders, in form of a company), his revenue is taxed at both company level and again at private level.

Can you spot the double taxation now?

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by lautis on Sunday January 22, 2012 @11:39AM (#3496927)
The corporation is a separate legal entity from it's owners, and thus is taxed separately. In step E the good being exchanged is money.
Re:The 15% Tax Rate by thurn on Sunday January 22, 2012 @03:07PM (#3497525)
There are other "separate legal entities" like partnerships and S-corps that don't get double taxed. Only corporations have this double taxation. That's why it's unfair.

The philosophy here is that you shouldn't get taxed on dividends because you're an owner... the money was already yours. The plumber didn't have to pay tax again to take his money out of his plumbing business (maybe a limited-liability partnership) and buy DVDs, but the shareholder did.

Re:The 15% Tax Rate by cperciva on Sunday January 22, 2012 @12:36PM (#3497093)
But eliminate the corporate income tax while you are at it.

Or switch to an integrated tax system like Canada has, where you get dividend tax credits (approximately) equal to the taxes the corporation paid on the revenues which resulted in those dividends.