So many men who are now experiencing problems with finding a partner now, say due to being a nasty/abusive/uninteresting/unintelligent/ugly, 80-100 years ago would be able to land a wife just by being the only person in the family who could provide. So in 2023, when they have to date equals, who are financially independent, they are experiencing “celibacy”.
Right now it’s a symptom of a much larger social-economic situation, with growing social isolation and poverty
If you're not talking to boys about Andrew Tate because it hasn't come up (because it would be too cringe, as the kids say), don't worry, YouTube (reposts) have got you covered.
I'm not sure what you're talking about here. If anything I was "casting shade" at you for your remark about how terrible young men are. You're the one defending someone calling them "nasty/abusive/uninteresting/unintelligent/ugly".
> If you're not talking to boys about Andrew Tate because it hasn't come up (because it would be too cringe, as the kids say), don't worry, YouTube (reposts) have got you covered.
I talk to men in their early 20s to 40s mostly, the guys who go to my BJJ gym. I can promise you not one of them gives a shit about Andrew Tate's "HoW To bE aN aLpHa MaLe" grift. Half of them have probably never even heard of him.
You accused me of being "part of the subset that spends too much time on the internet." Which like, you're here too, so that seems like a self-own.
You could have just said you own a BJ gym, interact with, and probably mentor many 20-40 year olds, and then talk about how they're not "nasty/abusive/uninteresting/unintelligent/ugly", but you went and made it all weird and personal for some reason.
Or as the guidelines state:
> "When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
You also seem eager to discard all people that "spend too much time on the Internet" for the crime of spending too much time on the Internet. Hey, guess which young men are single and sexless?
> I can promise you not one of them gives a shit about Andrew Tate's "HoW To bE aN aLpHa MaLe" grift.
I don't get how you can claim that they don't care about his shit if you've never actually brought him up with any of them.
Even then, if your using "people at your gym" as your final dataset then you've got a biased sample and your data's inaccurate, at best.
Hopefully you're better as a gym leader than you present yourself online.
I think you're assuming that the vocal minority of men who spend too much time on the internet is bigger than it is proportionally to the rest of the population
Anyway, this is a pattern I see weirdly often on HN--person A casually insults a large group of people, and person B calls them out on it. A proceeds to clutch pearls about "guidelines" being violated as if they didn't just say something vitriolic.
Also, I'm not sure how suggesting you spend too much time online is "calling names".
Back to the point: Commenting on HN isn't evidence of spending too much time online. Not knowing that Tate is a nobody outside of the internet is.
> I don't get how you can claim that they don't care about his shit if you've never actually brought him up with any of them.
Hence my accusation. The answer to this is obvious if you spend time around real people. How do you know your friends aren't flat earthers? Because those ideas appeal to a certain type of person, and they aren't that type (presumably).
There's a certain segment of the male population: insecure, awkward young guys who think that if only they can emulate the right behaviors, they'll "be a man", and for some reason their ability to get laid while displaying maximum disregard for their partner is the sole yardstick by which they measure their success. This is Tate's target audience. Ever heard of the "manosphere", internet personalities teaching guys "game" and how to "spin plates" and whatnot? Tate is just the latest iteration of that. He's not some new phenomenon.
I've known guys guys who follow that stuff. They're socially awkward, posturing, and have a thinly veiled resentment towards women. When they lay their "game" on some woman, which they often do at the most inappropriate possible time, everyone in earshot is usually silently dying of second hand embarrassment.
The guys at my gym are normal, fairly well-adjusted dudes. Relaxed, usually cracking jokes, supportive of their classmates both male and female. I know they don't follow Andrew Tate because he has nothing to offer them, and they don't act like the guys who are typically into that nonsense.
> Even then, if your using "people at your gym" as your final dataset then you've got a biased sample and your data's inaccurate, at best.
Imagine that, the guy who made the unsourced claim that 60% of men are $LIST_OF_SUBJECTIVE_NEGATIVE_THINGS expects only the most rigorous data from his opponents. LMAO. Where's your data coming from?
Sure, there may be females that are just looking for a male who is nice. But in general they are looking for a male who is nice and good looking and has high societal status.
Just as males are looking for females that are good looking and fertile.
That's what all animals do. They try to maximize their reproductive success. Humans are animals. And even though we have contraceptives that negate the effect of the behavior, the underlying drive and mechanisms are still the same.
When it comes to human societies; I don't buy that whole "patriarchal social constructs" thing.
Society is a matter of constant negotiation between the sexes, not something that is forced from one sex onto the other and set in stone. To believe that females are oppressed by males is to believe that females are helpless and fragile and need to be protected. Females can very much take care of themselves and are just as strong a force in shaping society - if not more so - than males.
Your simplistic view on reproductive behavior results in a completely misunderstood and sexist viewpoint which only serves to reinforce misunderstandings between the sexes.
Were women just voluntarily not voting in the US or what?
Voting rights were limited to rich men only. Poor men couldn't vote either. Only with the conscription into citizens' armies after the French revolution became it necessary for the "elites" to share their power. And soon after poor men gained suffrage, everyone gained suffrage. Go and check the development of voting rights in various democracies - you will find exactly this pattern.
So no; women have not been historically oppressed, not even in some highly religious societies.
Poor people have historically been oppressed. In any society.
Women had other roles than men. That doesn't mean they were oppressed. That narrative propagates capitalistic propaganda to turn the poor against themselves and to divert from the the fact that power always was limited to those with means. You know - the actual oppressors.
However the oppression of the poor has historically run in parallel with the oppression of women. In ancient societies, women were often excluded from political and public life, and their main role was to bear children and maintain the household. This was true in many early civilizations, such as ancient Greece, Rome, and China.
Religion also played a significant role in the oppression of women. Many religious traditions, such as Christianity, Islam, and Judaism, have traditionally placed women in subordinate roles, with men as the primary religious leaders and decision-makers.
Women were also subjected to practices such as foot-binding, female genital mutilation, and forced marriages. These practices aimed to control and limit women's movements and independence, and were often seen as necessary for maintaining social order.
Your assumption of "historically oppressed women" only works if you perceive of women as being told by men how to behave and what to do.
That's wrong. That is a fundamentally wrong understanding of how human societies work. Men are told how to behave by women and men. Women are told to behave by women and men.
Society and societal expectations are not something shaped by men. Is the construct of constant negotiations between both males and females.
As with regard to "women being in subordinate roles"; there I suggest you to read more about the dual hierarchies of males and females. Men and women had for a very, very long time separate hierarchies - and to some degree still do. While the male hierarchy is typically oriented out-of-family, female hierarchies are typically oriented into-family.
With the spread of agriculture and the rise of larger societies, the out-of-family hierarchies started to merge, creating larger and larger hierarchies with the family of the topmost male dominating this hierarchy. With time these hierarchies became the framework for legal and male-religious organization. That's why women hat to "break-in" to these hierarchies.
The into-family hierarchies stayed mostly separate, in the household, the tribe and usually didn't expand out of the family. The Mosuo people in China are one notable exception to that "rule".
> Women were also subjected to practices such as foot-binding, female genital mutilation, and forced marriages.
If you do some research you'll find that these things are not forced onto the females by men; they are forced onto the females by females and males. And if you find it abhorable that females' feet were bound - how angry will you be when you hear that most hard labor was forced onto men? Forced onto them by both men and women.
This whole "patriarchy" is really the invention of wealthy, fin de siècle bourgeoisie that was disgusted by the development of universal male suffrage; the rich will never let the poor have a share.
I suggest you read this blog:
https://sirtyrionlannister.wordpress.com/2014/03/21/how-the-...