News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by Scandiravian on Monday February 27, 2023 @10:45AM (#34957731)
I wish they'd included the results of the undervolted 7950x in the graphs (aka ECO mode)

It's sad that performance benchmarks have made market conditions where the gain of 5% performance is somehow worth 20%-30% extra power consumption (and the noise that follows from that)

Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by mastax on Monday February 27, 2023 @11:06AM (#34957997)
The X3D chips do at least have a reduced TDP of 120W vs 170W (except for the 7800X3D vs the confusingly comparable 7700X's 105W). The other thing is that, at least in DIY PC (and botique builders like CyberPower) the "gaming" motherboards universally increase the maximum peak power target and also commonly enable things like all core turbo and precision boost overdrive by default. So unless they specify otherwise, like AnandTech I think, you can assume most reviewers will be running the CPU with more power than the spec but that's a common situation for their audience.
Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by paulmd on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @11:29AM (#34984206)
> The other thing is that, at least in DIY PC (and botique builders like CyberPower) the "gaming" motherboards universally increase the maximum peak power target

Worth noting the PPT is higher than the TDP by default - a "120W" AMD chip is actually allowed to boost to 168W continuously, obviously they prefer to advertise the former and have people making comparisons between "120W" AMD and Intel chips running at full boost PPT.

A "170W" AMD chip like the 7950X is allowed to boost to 220W and that's where it really gets spicy because that puts them in the same power class as Intel. 7950X3D is a step above the rest of the market in terms of efficiency, but with the non-X3D chips, the difference between marketing your chip as 170W and marketing it as the true 220W it's allowed to pull is pretty significant, that erases most of the difference vs Intel (or creates a perceived difference out of nothing). And that actually carries down the rest of the line as well, people reflexively think in terms of AMD's marketing TDP numbers when they're making comparisons against Intel, giving them an instant 30% edge in all comparisons.

That part is not something that gaming motherboards do automatically, and I've never seen one that will enable multicore enhancement-style tuning by default. If you enable overclocking yourself (and enabling XMP/DOCP is considered overclocking since this usually increases VSOC or VCCSA to allow the memory controller to run faster) then all bets are off but by default no, they shouldn't be, just the terminology difference that springs from AMD's marketing trickery.

PBO is the setting where you'd see power limits increased and I've never seen that on by default.

Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by alyandon on Monday February 27, 2023 @10:52AM (#34957826)
I just disable PBO on my 3900X - you are 100% correct that an extra 5% performance is not worth the extra 30% power draw/heat.
Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by CharlesW on Monday February 27, 2023 @11:34AM (#34958429)
For anyone else not familiar with "PBO", it's AMD's "Precision Boost Overdrive", which is apparently completely different than Precision Boost and Precision Boost 2: https://www.gamersnexus.net/guides/3491-explaining-precision...
Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by caycep on Monday February 27, 2023 @11:57AM (#34958796)
This is the same as AMD "Eco Mode"?
Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by 0cf8612b2e1e on Monday February 27, 2023 @12:04PM (#34958907)
I just turned on Eco Mode last night and was pleasantly surprised. In a non rigorous test on my 5600x, Eco Mode had zero change to single core performance, unchanged CPU temp. Multicore saw a 3% performance drop, but temps were ~12C cooler.

Test yourself, but I am definitely going to leave it enabled.

Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by merb on Monday February 27, 2023 @03:46PM (#34961636)
a 5600x runs at only 65w or so and can be cooled down to 40C like all the time. I'm not sure if I would prefer to run it at 16w lower, because I bareley even reach the tdp or even tjmax.
Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by anticensor on Monday February 27, 2023 @03:15PM (#34961324)
PBO also allows undervolting though: I just applied -30 all core offset on my 5950X.
Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by asynchronyse on Monday February 27, 2023 @07:06PM (#34963918)
I'm wondering how much clock speed you gave up to achieve stability at -30.

I could barely be stable at -15 all core on a 5900X at zero clock offset.

Re:AMD releases a new flagship CPU for consumer market with ... by anticensor on Friday March 10, 2023 @01:32AM (#35091132)
About 300Mhz on each core on average, but the peak frequency on the best core did not change.