News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by ivankirigin on Saturday January 21, 2012 @11:48AM (#3493901)
Lobbying is legal. Donating to campaigns of politicians you like is legal. I'm not sure why people are surprised.

The answer isn't to kick these specific bums out. It is to change campaign finance laws to make contributions illegal. I'm not sure what people here would agree to that doesn't amount to censorship though. Should the MPAA be disallowed to make a political commercial and pay for its broadcast?

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by pacemkr on Saturday January 21, 2012 @02:33PM (#3494341)
Nicely summarized and a valid question.

From what I gather, direct campaign contributions and the way corporations are funneling money into elections are not connected. Corporations are NOT making direct contributions to campaigns. They are making indirect and anonymous contributions to superpacs.

We don't need to "make contributions illegal." Nor do we _need_ publicly financed campaigns. That would be very hard to get.

We can start by having superpacs disclose their donors. Or by setting a limit on individual, and by extension corporate, contribution to said superpacs.

The loophole is that you can't make a large contribution directly to a campaign, yet you can make a contribution of any size, anonymously, indirectly to the corresponding superpac. This is why money = voice.

In answer to your question: "Should the MPAA be disallowed to make a political commercial and pay for its broadcast?" They should be allowed to make a political statement by contributing to a superpac that runs the commercial, but the contribution should not be unlimited nor anonymous. In effect, they'll need other companies in the pool to get enough money for that commercial. Now we can say corporations are people, problem solved.

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by yummyfajitas on Saturday January 21, 2012 @07:52PM (#3495218)
I think you are making the implicit assumption that some people should not have a greater voice than others. Is that correct?

If so, do you favor removing Paul Krugman or Glenn Beck's bully pulpit? If not, why not?

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by pacemkr on Sunday January 22, 2012 @12:15AM (#3495725)
The implicit assumption is that you shouldn't have the legislator's ear because you have a fat check in hand. Chance are that the check will win over a petition.

If we are to have freedom of speech, then Beck should be able to have his show. That's the easy part.

Beck converts money into public opinion. Arguably, SuperPACs do the same. Hence the Citizens United decision. In practice, SuperPAC donors just tell the legislator why the check was written, or in which case it will be. Nothing wrong with the premise (free speech), plenty wrong with the outcome (money = voice, or rather money = ear?)

Now that I ran this circle, I can see how publicly financed campaigns might be the only answer. Thank you for asking a difficult question to answer. I'll definitely think about this more.

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by yummyfajitas on Sunday January 22, 2012 @12:55AM (#3495794)
In practice, SuperPAC donors just tell the legislator why the check was written, or in which case it will be.

If it were not a check, but merely using influence, would things be better? I.e., if Krugman were to offer to endorse Romney only on the condition that Romney expands Obama/Romneycare, would that be acceptable?

Or how about if some rich person stated he would buy a newspaper and use the newspaper to push Romney?

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by nextparadigms on Saturday January 21, 2012 @04:35PM (#3494714)
How about capping the donations? I really don't like how a few entities/persons can have such a dramatic impact on elections because of how much they donate to that politician.

The vote is equal in a democracy, but donations aren't, and in a way donations are like a parallel vote, which huge discrepancies between each donation. Obviously the politician will listen to his biggest donors first, even if 10,000 of his normal supporters want the opposite thing.

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by pacemkr on Saturday January 21, 2012 @05:54PM (#3494935)
Direct contributions are capped at $5,000. SuperPAC contributions are not capped at all and are anonymous until well after the election. [wikipedia]
Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by anamax on Saturday January 21, 2012 @12:52PM (#3494079)
> Should the MPAA be disallowed to make a political commercial and pay for its broadcast?

The MPAA has been known to make Dem-friendly movies. How do you distinguish between that and a commercial?

Note that Citizens United was about a movie, not a commercial.

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by necubi on Saturday January 21, 2012 @01:03PM (#3494121)
People pay you to see movies. You pay other people to watch commercials.
Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by jinushaun on Saturday January 21, 2012 @12:19PM (#3493988)
That is the heart of Citizens United v FEC.
Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by ivankirigin on Saturday January 21, 2012 @11:03PM (#3495587)
I don't really think Citizens United has the implications people give to it. For example, there is little to stop the MPAA from giving its head a big bonus, and then that individual making a commercial or movie to political ends. What is the difference between that commercial and something I post on youtube expressing my opinion?

Money flows into politics because of the power of government. One of the only ways I see to limit that money without limiting speech is to limit the power of government.

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by jbooth on Sunday January 22, 2012 @09:41AM (#3496626)
Unless you're talking about abolishing the commerce clause and the ability of congress to make laws, good luck with that.

I'd set my sights on the somewhat easier "limit the ability to bribe government".

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by gaulinmp on Saturday January 21, 2012 @05:18PM (#3494835)
I am also confused by the uproar about this, why is what Dodd said wrong? Are campaign contributions not a sign that you support the goals of the politician in question? So if that politician is no longer espousing your values, you move your contributions somewhere else.

I guess my question comes down to what is the difference between contributing to whichever campaign forwards a platform and bribery (the assumption that Dodd was engaging in the latter being what caused the furor)?

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by furyofantares on Sunday January 22, 2012 @02:05AM (#3495912)
> I guess my question comes down to what is the difference between contributing to whichever campaign forwards a platform and bribery (the assumption that Dodd was engaging in the latter being what caused the furor)?

Dodd's implication is that the politicians should not have listened to their constituents. Or at least that's how I pick up on it. The tone says to me that his money should have solidified or shaped the opinions of those his industry donated to.

That's very different from trying to get someone elected because you believe their view of how to best serve their constituents aligns with your platform. Now, I'm sure you will find many people here who will argue that that, too, is corrupt. But it's not so blatant.

However, there's one more piece to the puzzle: None of the politicians have said they are going to give up on passing legislation that fights copyright infringement. They've shelved two bills, that's it. They haven't announced any bad intentions toward his platform, and they haven't established a pattern of ignoring his platform. So to claim that they aren't supporting his platform would be a gross overreaction. It more like Dodd feels his industry is entitled to these particular bills, and he is whining that they didn't get them.

Re:MPAA Publicly Threatens to Stop Writing Checks by uxp on Saturday January 21, 2012 @06:28PM (#3495021)
> I am also confused by the uproar about this, why is what Dodd said wrong

It's not that people are upset that he is freely admitting to bribery or lobbying (depending on your viewpoint), but that is should be wrong for him to be admitting it. You are totally right. If I stand behind a congressman or woman because I agree with their actions and values, then one day I notice that they are supporting things that I am against, no one should be upset if I move my donations and support elsewhere. The problem comes from how he openly admits to the influence everyone already knows the media industry has over our legislative body.

If the media industry is as massive as they claim it to be, then every single one of those people employed in that industry has a right to support and back congressmen and women that support the values that help them strengthen their industry. The fact that the industry itself can, in parallel to those that work in the industry, also donate and support congressmen and women is the problem, as it creates exponential power with linear growth (if everyone was hypothetically contributing equally to the industry).

The same idea applies to any industry, really. No one ideally wants to reduce the size of any industry, but to limit the power any single industry has over the direction the country drafts it's laws to help and protect to be fair to everyone.