Re:Why College Students Leave the Engineering Track
by arctangent on Friday January 20, 2012 @07:44PM
(#3492059)
I'd agree that Philosophy is a tough subject.
The reason I'd give for this is that in some sense philosophy does have correct answers, if and only if a question is framed within an existing philosophical model.
The point of philosophy (as I see it) is trying to work out which philosophical model is most correct - a bit like a choosing between scientific theories.
Instead of testing against measurable things in the real world, philosophers derive logical outcomes from propositions within linguistic/logical systems and compare them to detect inconsistencies.
Therefore it's fine to ask a question about the consequences of a particular line of thought if a particular philosophical framework is specified, because you can mark a student not only on whether they arrived at an expected answer but also on the quality of their argument (i.e. how they got there).
The reason I'd give for this is that in some sense philosophy does have correct answers, if and only if a question is framed within an existing philosophical model.
The point of philosophy (as I see it) is trying to work out which philosophical model is most correct - a bit like a choosing between scientific theories.
Instead of testing against measurable things in the real world, philosophers derive logical outcomes from propositions within linguistic/logical systems and compare them to detect inconsistencies.
Therefore it's fine to ask a question about the consequences of a particular line of thought if a particular philosophical framework is specified, because you can mark a student not only on whether they arrived at an expected answer but also on the quality of their argument (i.e. how they got there).