News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by freejazz on Thursday February 23, 2023 @05:55PM (#34917924)
But those aren't criminal proceedings, they don't have any of the requirements of a fair trial... are you saying that any time a private institution does anything that can have an adverse effect on an individual, they need to employ the standards of criminal law? have you even remotely considered what that would entail? or you are you just being smarmy online.

also, who would enforce it? say your company gives you a negative review because they don't like your work product - they now need to empanel a jury, and a judge? how is that going to work? if they don't, I'd imagine it'd have to be a criminal penalty because what would be the point if it was just civil? so now the gov't is forcing your company to have a trial over your review? give me a break, dude.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by viscanti on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:19PM (#34926950)
> so now the gov't is forcing your company to have a trial over your review?

No. But if the consequence of an anonymous report causes you to lose your job, and potentially be blacklisted from any other academic jobs in the future, it seems prudent that some process would exist to make sure things are fair. Otherwise it can be abused and weaponized by people in ways most people wouldn't want to see. I don't see anyone arguing the government should do anything here. It appears to be an argument that institutions instituting new policies like the one mentioned in the linked post should have some kind of process to prevent them from being abused.

Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa... by freejazz on Friday February 24, 2023 @01:22PM (#34927855)
>I don't see anyone arguing the government should do anything here.

Maybe work on your reading comprehension? People are literally saying that due process should apply... I had a dozens-long interaction with someone insisting that the constitution is a set of principles that apply to any human interactions... there's massive misunderstanding proliferated around here, so I don't agree at all.

> It appears to be an argument that institutions instituting new policies like the one mentioned in the linked post should have some kind of process to prevent them from being abused.

No shit - did you see anyone arguing that they should just be processes that are rife for abuse? The question is "what is the standard?"