Re:Stanford Faculty Say Anonymous Student Bias Reports Threa...
by dragonwriter on Thursday February 23, 2023 @05:49PM
(#34917833)
> It’s that the rationale made sense for criminal cases, and because it makes sense there, it should be included by others (say an HR department coming up with a policy on how to do something with anonymous reports).
The rationale for the explicitly criminal protections in the legal system, whether in the Constitution (like the Confrontation Clause at issue here) or the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard that reaches back to English common law, is that criminal convictions regularly and explicitly result in noncompensable loss of rights, sometimes including life.
HR is not imprisoning or imposing corporal or capital punishments, the same rationale does not apply.
The rationale for the explicitly criminal protections in the legal system, whether in the Constitution (like the Confrontation Clause at issue here) or the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard that reaches back to English common law, is that criminal convictions regularly and explicitly result in noncompensable loss of rights, sometimes including life.
HR is not imprisoning or imposing corporal or capital punishments, the same rationale does not apply.