Re:Ask HN: Why is hiring so dehumanized, and what can be done?
by lapcat on Thursday February 23, 2023 @08:47AM
(#34910502)
> It doesn't have to be one central guild. There can be a competition of guilds, each with their own criteria.
But that totally undermines the central premise:
> Employers at first communicate with the guild and only have to evaluate 5-10 candidates.
For employers, there's no reason or advantage to deal with the guilds rather than directly with job candidates when there are a bunch of competing guilds with their own criteria.
And if guilds aren't providing/gatekeeping access to employers, then why would job candidates join them?
But that totally undermines the central premise:
> Employers at first communicate with the guild and only have to evaluate 5-10 candidates.
For employers, there's no reason or advantage to deal with the guilds rather than directly with job candidates when there are a bunch of competing guilds with their own criteria.
And if guilds aren't providing/gatekeeping access to employers, then why would job candidates join them?