The best advice I can give is to make sure you have agreement on the terms up front. If someone seems uneasy, don't move ahead. Find a way to agree. In our case, one of the founders who exited:
* Continually brought up the fact that he had loaned the company money as a leverage point
* After some time (over a year) decided to make an issue over the terms he agreed to
We managed to negotiate an amicable exit, but boy was it tough.
On balance do you think you (all) did the right thing at the time (for the company) or could you have done something different earlier on?
Also, had you worked with this person before?
An uneasy consensus is not a consensus. When founding a company, consensus is critical in matters of finance.
I think we could have done something different, but I'm not sure I'd trade our current circumstances on an unknown. I think that ultimately, losing those two founders was the right thing. They probably shouldn't have been a part of the company to begin with. Maybe I should revise my statement of "find a way to agree" to "find a way to agree completely, or don't move ahead". Finding the line between uneasy and unworkable is something you learn with experience.
I worked with the person before, but only in terms of work. My working contractual relationship was with his employer, with me acting as a third-party contractor. I found myself positioned as a moderate between two extreme fiscal viewpoints, one that placed a high value on the time value of money, and one that placed hardly any value there. I did not recognize at the time that this is a "founder smell" (vis-à-vis, a code smell). I thought that the two fiscally conservative members could bring discipline to the group.
What I later realized is that the behavior of a group is not equivalent to an average of the individual members' personalities. This seems obvious, but you'd be amazed how often people act on this very premise.
The problem with negotiating little details of ownership early is that anyone who believes they did not negotiate well is likely to feel taken advantage of.
I wonder if issuing convertible debt would be a good solution. So then you are giving equity to reward the founder for taking on the high risk of not being repaid, but you let future investment determine how much they should get.
If founders want to fundraise then the question of equity vs salary is likely to be moot.
The point about the risk of default is real but I wouldn't say that 'deserves substantial additional compensation'. If they're putting in substantial funds then yes, that's more like investment but if we're talking about comparatively small sums (as I believe Spolsky was referring to) then I see it as less of an issue. Presumably, all founders have aligned interests. Also, you could argue that founders still have the opportunity cost of not taking those high-paying job in MegaCorp.
The expected value of a $100k IOU from a startup is likely $10-20k.
The expected value of $100k in equity is (if priced reasonably) roughly $100k even though the value in case of default is $0.
If somebody was really adamant with me about IOUs being treated equivalent to cash, I'd ask if we could simplify and just pay all the founders equally, at the same time to get rid of the discussion.
The challenge, however, is not to identify the time value of money and the inherent risks of not taking a salary. The problem is to quantify those risks and costs in a way which all the cofounders will consider fair...all the while recognizing that forty percent of a startup is probably worth just as much as sixty percent, i.e. Nothing.
The second group face not only a time value of money problem, but they're also accepting the risk of default (which is fairly likely in startups). They deserve substantial additional compensation for their willingness to leave capital in the company during early growth. One potentially fair way to do this would be to give them convertible notes with the same terms as whatever your first external angels get.
After all, leaving $100,000 in the startup's bank account has the same net effect as drawing the salary, then investing $100,000 in the startup.