The fact is, "states rights", and the whole idealization of the pre-Civil War system in America, is a broken and evil ideology that was used as an indirect defense of slavery in the 19th century and segregation and disenfranchisement in the 20th. What you are really saying is that you value that system of government so much that you would prefer to let people continue to be enslaved until such time as their enslavers felt so inclined as to free them out of their own moral goodness. And I would like to know why.
[1] This is an interesting precursor to contemporary complaints about big business, for instance Wal-Mart. Today, people complain that Wal-Mart is a huge company that puts local businesses out of business. In the 19th century, people complained that plantation slaveowners were rich people who put small-time family farms out of business, especially if slavery were legal in the expanded western territories. Legalized slavery would allow slaveowners to expand their operations and use their stock of slaves to farm a lot of land at scale, leaving nothing left for the white settler who wanted to go build his own farm in the west.
In the US, in other countries it was the abolitionist movement and that was my point. Even in the US it was the appeasement of strong abolitionist, preservation of the Union at any cost was always the foremost concern, Lincoln said so himself, the moral argument of the issue was always secondary to preservation of the Union.
We will never know if the institution of slavery would have ended peacefully, but what we do know is that culturally slavery was becoming unsavory, the abolitionist where winning the moral argument, as they had done in England and we do know that the war and ensuing reconstruction brought bitterness and resentment that lasted for almost another 100 years. There are some who believe that the cultural trend, that was happening around the globe would have continued and that slavery would have lost the moral argument bringing about it's demise by peaceful measures. If that is the case then the war was a travesty, because we may have saved ourselves 100 more years of immorality and a second social uprising to finally and truly free the all people and that is the problem with war, you only get to see the victors side of history.