Re:Wikipedia Outage
by justeleblanc on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @04:53AM
(#34893614)
It's already back up. Was this post really necessary?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I'm not sure that the person who submitted this could have considered the fact that the service has now been restored, regardless of how imminent the restoration was.
It's an interesting event (albeit it relatively low impact one) which we would not have known about if it wasn't posted here. Also, check out the wikimedia service status page, pretty cool, huh?
Indeed. I not only find it impressive how honest it is (as opposed to others[1]) but also how quickly they resolved the event.
[1] - https://ably.com/blog/honest-status-reporting-aws-service
Re:Wikipedia Outage
by justeleblanc on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:43PM
(#34900550)
The incident took ten minutes to resolve. What's the point of immediately rushing to HN whenever a large website is transiently down?
These kinds of posts are interesting to learn more about the architectures and failure modes at play.
I agree that HN should not be a down detector but for a high profile service with infrequent outages like Wikipedia in this instance, a post with discussion is acceptable in my eyes.