Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An...
by sdenton4 on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:40PM
(#34890907)
Eh, the way I've used these tools are so interactive and iterative that I would absolutely say the output is my work, or at most a collaboration.
Did you dig the hole, or the backhoe you were driving?
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An...
by Centigonal on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:34PM
(#34890847)
You're asserting that ChatGPT is closer to a person than a tool. I don't think this is a settled debate yet.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An...
by hresvelgr on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:53PM
(#34891024)
I wouldn't say it's closer to a person, more simply that to claim it's work verbatim and without substantial modification as your own is perhaps dubious and not entirely honest. Even then, "substantial modification" is somewhat arbitrary. Definitely an interesting philosophical topic.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An...
by greesil on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:55PM
(#34891042)
You're serious?
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An...
by Centigonal on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @09:22AM
(#34895941)
Yes. I'm not saying LLMs are sentient (corporations are people and similarly not sentient, under the traditional definition of the word), I'm saying there's an active debate on how to view AI, especially in the context of attribution.
If you used Photoshop to manipulate an image over using MS Paint, you wouldn't say that Photoshop made the image for you, because it didn't, you did. Grammarly doesn't write your articles for you, you do. They just maximise your efforts.