News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft is now injecting full-size ads on Chrome website by hajile on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @08:49PM (#34890476)
MS had to add content to the page then render that new content. That would count as a derivative work which would be covered by copyright.

Normally, when a user does this themselves, it isn't for commercial purposes which puts it in a different category (plus, the most popular modification involves stuff from loading onto a device rather than modifying the stuff that was loaded). This is far different in intent.

Re:Microsoft is now injecting full-size ads on Chrome website by ethbr0 on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:27PM (#34890783)
By this logic, no one would be able to serve banner ads on top of copywritten content.

Plenty of existing and historical malware browsers and plugins have injected ads.

Furthermore, because it's a full page width banner, it's not entirely clear whether Edge is rending something next to Google's page (i.e. in MS' browser) or in Google's page (i.e. commingled with their content).

Re:Microsoft is now injecting full-size ads on Chrome website by midoridensha on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:44AM (#34892081)
I think your logic is flawed. Banner ads are explicitly permitted by the web site operator (they get paid for them after all). Plugins aren't permitted by the web site operator, however they are permitted by the user, who has to explicitly approve installation of the plugin. Same with malware browsers: the users chose those. Of course, the users were ignorant and clicked on something they shouldn't have, but still it's ultimately their own fault: they opted in.

It's different with Microsoft: MS never asked for users' permission to change content, nor did users ever expect it.

Re:Microsoft is now injecting full-size ads on Chrome website by ethbr0 on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @08:57AM (#34895524)
How do you get from 'users opted into malware browsers/plugins' to 'users didn't opt-in to Edge/Windows'?
Re:Microsoft is now injecting full-size ads on Chrome website by midoridensha on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @07:50PM (#34905327)
Edge comes with Windows, and users pick Windows because it's the default choice and basically a monopoly for PC operating systems.
Re:Microsoft is now injecting full-size ads on Chrome website by 1123581321 on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:46PM (#34890963)
I don't think a browser render counts as creating potentially infringing content. I'm at a loss to explain why but I think it's the ephemerality of a browser render and the lack of a distribution method. Where are you getting the idea that infringement is possible at all by the browser itself, regardless of fair use laws?