HAART leaves people extremely vulnerable to infection as well, after all. The difference is that HAART means that point will come at some unpredictable point in the future, whereas a bone marrow transplant makes the window more predictable. And beyond that, it fails to consider the risks of decades of really toxic medication.
Is a bone marrow transplant really worse than decades of liver damage followed by developing AIDS eventually anyway?
Maybe, maybe not, but dismissing the heavy questions of a persons life with "basically normal" is not helpful.
> And beyond that, it fails to consider the risks of decades of really toxic medication. Is a bone marrow transplant really worse than decades of liver damage followed by developing AIDS eventually anyway?
This is an outdated and objectively incorrect description of HAART.
> but dismissing the heavy questions of a persons life with "basically normal" is not helpful.
"Basically normal" is an approximately correct description of the life of most HIV+ people who have easy access to HAART. What's not helpful is responding to that with fearmongering based on incorrect and/or grossly outdated information.
There's a difference between fearmongering and informed consent, and I would ask you to refrain both from spreading misinformation and from making personal attacks.
Your comment literally claims that long-term HAART carries a significant (or even certain) risk of long-term liver damage, a claim which is baseless and unsupported.
You're also conflating acute adverse reactions - which are astronomically rare - with long-term side-effects, when there's no relationship between the two.
Not only are tenofovir and emtricitabine safe for the liver, but they are literally commonly prescribed for people who have chronic liver problems because they are so well tolerated. People who can't take Tylenol are able to take them. It's a gross mischaracterization to suggest that they cause "decades of liver damage", a claim which is soundly contradicted by medical literature.
> There's a difference between fearmongering and informed consent, and I would ask you to refrain both from spreading misinformation and from making personal attacks.
I never made any personal attack at any point.
I would, however, flip this request back at you and ask you to stop spreading misinformation, which is what you are clearly doing.
> Your insistence on gaslighting does not lend credibility to your other claims.
Your comparison to Tylenol is misleading. People aren't required to receive regular liver enzyme tests before being allowed to use Tylenol.
Read the guidelines yourself. Accusing people of fearmongering is a personal attack. If you think I'm wrong (and the FDA is wrong) about the risk of liver damage, feel free to present that evidence here (or better yet, to the FDA, so people can have better access to PrEP). Don't make false and ad hominem claims about my motivations. It's unacceptable behavior.
People aren't required to receive "regular liver enzyme tests" before taking these drugs either.
> free to present that evidence here
You've made a lot of claims without presenting any evidence to back any of them up. Moreover, your claims could be trivially debunked by even a cursory search. The burden is not on me or others to do that work when you yourself present zero evidence for any of the fantastical claims you make.
> Don't make false and ad hominem claims about my motivations.
I never made any claim about your motivation. "Fearmongering" is a specific, descriptive term about your actions, the effect they have on others, and their factual basis (or lack thereof).
On the other hand, you accused me of gaslighting (before editing it out of your comment and replacing it with a different accusation). That is an ad hominem attack, ascribing specific and malicious motivations.
Also: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/fearm...
It's an ad hominem.
Incorrect. A one-time test of liver function was previously sometimes suggested before starting PrEP specifically... but not for the reason you think. And it was never required.
Ongoing liver enzyme tests are neither required nor recommended. In fact, Truvada and Descovy were shown to be so safe during clinical trials that routine liver function tests are explicitly contraindicated for patients with no other comorbidities.
> It's an ad hominem.
Even if I were accusing you of intentionally spreading fear and misinformation, that still would not be an ad hominem: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem
You are correct. I was mistaken.
> Even if I were accusing you of intentionally spreading fear and misinformation
You were. That's what the word means.
> that still would not be an ad hominem
It would not constitute an ad hominem fallacy. It is still an ad hominem attack and is still deeply unproductive.
From 2011 to 2016, overall life expectancy at 21 years of age for individuals with HIV infection who initiated ART at a CD4 cell count of 500/μL or greater was 57.4 years (95% CI, 55.7-59.1 years) and for uninfected adults was 64.2 years (95% CI, 64.0-64.4 years), corresponding to a difference of 6.8 years (95% CI, 5.0-8.5 years)
The risk profile for a full bone marrow transplant for treating HIV vs HAART for a difference of ~5-9 years is just not there.According to whom? Who gets to make the choice between 57 years of drugs and stigma versus 64 years of being cured?
Based on their 2010 alloHCT volume, centers were categorized as low-volume (≤40 alloHCTs; N=42 centers, 1,900 recipients) or high-volume (>40 alloHCTs; N=41 centers, 9,637 recipients). 100-day survival was 86% (95% CI, 85–87%) in high-volume compared to 83% (95% CI, 81–85%) in low-volume centers (difference 3%; P<0.001). One-year survival was 62% (95% CI, 61–63%) and 56% (95% CI, 54–58%), respectively (difference 6%; P < 0.001).
You are literally getting a coin flip of surviving past 2 years after an allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplant. If I was given the choice of HAART and living a mostly normal lifespan, or maybe die with a coin flip chance in 2 years, I would pick HAART, no contest.Not to mention that the "64 years" comparison is not the correct reference point here, because it's talking about people who were never infected with HIV in the first place, not people who have received a stem cell transplant.
The stem cell transplant almost certainly reduces both your lifespan and QALS in the long term, not just the first two years. Yes, it might be worth it if you have cancer, but it's not like it suddenly makes you clinically equivalent to a person who has never had HIV!
In contrast, HAART for HIV is far less risky and far more safe, allowing people with HIV to live basically a normal life as long as their viral loads stay at undetectable limits.