News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by jiggawatts on Monday February 20, 2023 @12:02AM (#34865090)
This!

99% of modern physics was developed for pen & paper mathematics, not numeric simulations. Even when computers became readily available, there was the issue that it was seen as somehow "less than" symbolic solutions. More practically, special-case solutions that were tractable symbolically would require far too much computer power if approached from a "local" simulation perspective.

Essentially QED is "just" Monte Carlo, just like traditional computer graphics rendering of 3D scenes as seen in computer games or Pixar movies. The difference is that QED will correctly model diffraction (and other more complex effects) that the simplified grapics-only model doesn't bother with.

This relies on a mathematical dualism where a wavefront can be simulated either as a surface OR as a vector perpendicular to the wavefront. The whole "summing up but mostly cancelling" is just the mathematics of ray-tracing work such that it matches what the electromagnetic waves do.

If you skip the "waves" part, it becomes traditional computer graphics. Less accurate, but essentially the same.

Computer graphics could also simply simulate light transport by using a 3D volume, which is more-or-less how some diffuse light simulations work in real time games like the Unreal engine. The problem is that to get decent accuracy, you need a lot of memory to store that 3D volume. Monte Carlo enables a solution to be build up incrementally with much less memory required (a 2D accumulator in the image plane instead of a 3D simulation in object space).

For a physics problem the memory requirements of any non-trivial system would be gigantic, that's why everyone just ignores this approach even though it makes a lot more intuitive sense.

Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by consilient on Monday February 20, 2023 @12:56AM (#34865374)
> that's why everyone just ignores this approach even though it makes a lot more intuitive sense.

- No one ignores the correspondence between QFTs and stochastic processes (which is what I assume you're talking about, since the claim that QED is just Monte Carlo is extremely false if taken literally), any halfway decent intro QFT class will cover it.

- It only "makes more intuitive sense" because you've papered over all the gory details. There's very little intuitive or natural about analytic continuation in C^{\infty}, for instance.

Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by trashtester on Monday February 20, 2023 @05:28AM (#34866872)
Stochastic processes is one thing. But most calculations in QFT is done using various perturbation theories (kind of like Taylor series expansion), instead of by using exact calculation.

That could be interpreted kind of like ray tracing with finite resolution and a finite number of reflections.

EDIT: Feynman diagrams serve as an attractive way to rationalize the various perturbations, but it may be that a "true" theory needs to be able to solve the (for us) unsolvable integrals directly.

Especially since the perturbation theory integrals (that we can solve) diverge, and require renormalization to avoid infinities.

Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by BrandoElFollito on Monday February 20, 2023 @03:44AM (#34866315)
> it was seen as somehow "less than" symbolic solutions

This reminds me of an old prof during my PhD studies (physics) who was always telling how immature and simple minded computer users were.

I told him once that using a computer requires intelligence and aptitudes that some people who criticize indeed lack.

It did not go well.

Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by Karellen on Monday February 20, 2023 @05:28AM (#34866874)
> It did not go well.

Insulting people rarely does.

Even if the insult is unintended, or is plausibly deniable, if the person ends up being insulted anyway, then it is unlikely to go well.

In totally unrelated news, it might be worth noting that "being right" is not a relevant defence against the charge of "being an asshole". It's entirely possible to be one without being the other.

Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by BrandoElFollito on Monday February 20, 2023 @07:00AM (#34867310)
See, there is a tendency for students to feel like they have to take on them any insults (or similar) coming from a higher-up.

I understand that you are fine being called an idiot and that the proper response is a smile and nod of understanding. Some do not. I do not.

Have you worked in academia, especially in the ones where you have a medieval approach to hierarchy?

EDIT: something liake http://amandabauer.blogspot.com/2011/08/how-academics-see-ea... (the humorous way of looking at it)

Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by criddell on Monday February 20, 2023 @09:37AM (#34868457)
> I understand that you are fine being called an idiot and that the proper response is a smile and nod of understanding.

How did you come to this understanding?

Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by Karellen on Monday February 20, 2023 @11:24AM (#34869604)
> I understand that you are fine being called an idiot and that the proper response is a smile and nod of understanding. Some do not. I do not.

Because the only possible responses are "smile and nod of understanding" and "call the professor an idiot in return", and no middle ground exists where you can draw attention to someone's mistaken beliefs without escalating the situation, or even without putting them on the defensive?

I don't believe you believe that.

Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by BrandoElFollito on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @05:52AM (#34879479)
> you can draw attention to someone's mistaken beliefs without escalating the situation, or even without putting them on the defensive?

This requires a will to discuss (both sides). I have had plenty of such discussions where the other side arguments sinked in or not, but where the was will to actually listen and think.

I don't believe you only met such people, and if so congratulations (I am not being cynical - it would really be great).

Unfortunately this was not the case, not even close. He was an asshole using his power to dominate others, something which works in some places where there is a medieval structure.

I did not friends on him and he said that we would meet at my defence where he will remember that. To what I said that I don't do, but wish him all the best.

He was childishly ridicule at the defense where he absolutely wanted to be part of the jury.

The world is sadly what it is. My life motto is "always be nice twice" (stolen from Irving) and I like to be the one extending the hand after a failed first meeting. Some take this as weakness or submission, and well, b it does not go well indeed.

Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by danaris on Monday February 20, 2023 @08:53AM (#34868053)
And why are you pointing this at the GP, and not sparing any of it for the professor who insulted him to his face first?
Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by orbifold on Monday February 20, 2023 @05:19AM (#34866820)
While in principle you can evaluate certain path integrals by using MCMC, in practice you run into all kinds of issues like the sign problem, which even with things like complex Langevin dynamics can't be resolved to this day completely.
Re:Our Reality May Be a Sum of All Possible Realities by credit_guy on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @07:35AM (#34880389)
This sounds like a very intuitive way of understanding quanum mechanics. Do you have any links for this analogy?