Re:Never use a URL shortening service – even if you own it
by JohnFen on Sunday February 19, 2023 @02:37PM
(#34861009)
> Just because it's not necessarily having to do a lookup?
Yes. You aren't shortening a URL, you are serving a web page that has a short URL.
I realize this is pedantic, but the relevance is that we're talking about URL shortening services, which this is not using.
I don't mind short URLs much (although I greatly appreciate it if the URL gives me some hint of the content it's pointing at, even if that makes it longer). URL shortening, however, comes with additional problems that lead me to the opinion that they're unacceptable.
Yes. You aren't shortening a URL, you are serving a web page that has a short URL.
I realize this is pedantic, but the relevance is that we're talking about URL shortening services, which this is not using.
I don't mind short URLs much (although I greatly appreciate it if the URL gives me some hint of the content it's pointing at, even if that makes it longer). URL shortening, however, comes with additional problems that lead me to the opinion that they're unacceptable.