Also, the offspring of the man in question identifies an aspect of his temperament that led to things turning out the way they did.
People start businesses for emotional reasons, not logical ones, and vastly, vastly underestimate the amount of money they'll need to get the thing off the ground. Entrepreneurial people are inherently optimistic, (and they have to be), but he said their estimates were typically off by ~5x. If you think you need a million dollars of runway, you probably need 5 million. If you think it'll take a year to achieve profitability, it'll probably take 5 years.
Ironically, that’s what VC funding aims to provide - capital to extend runway and improve scale quickly.
Whereas the reality is VCs support negative unit economics and absurd customer acquisition costs.
Having seen my share of failed businesses - I'm very skeptical of these numbers.
When you start a business, your costs basically fall into 3 categories: initial costs (like furniture and stove-tops), fixed costs (like rent and bare-minimum employee wages), and variable costs (like raw input ingredients and additional labor to handle additional business).
As long as your revenue is growing each month, and you're making money on each individual sale (as determined by your variable costs), you'll eventually achieve profitability.
When I say most new businesses have no fundamental flaw in their business plan, I mean that most businesses make money on each sale (e.g. they're not selling burgers for less than the cost of ingredients and the labor to prepare it), which is not that surprising. What is perhaps surprising is that the business is also usually growing each month and they're on a path to eventual profitability, yet they run out of money and fail anyway. When starting a business, you're not convincing investors and debtors that your business model is sound (most are), but rather, that your business model is more sound than most other businesses that they can invest in.
'Bootstrapped' as we now say, 'mom and pop' as many here might say, or just 'small to medium businesses' as we used to say.
There are a lot of moving parts, a lot to learn, and timing/luck are also factors. Until they all hit at the same time, it looks like a flop. It takes time to find, learn, or assemble all the key bits.
Sorry your dad's impatience was so persistent. Sense of urgency is important, but impatience is deadly. Thanks for sharing such a clear example.
Are some businesses under capitalised? Sure. Could "loads" be saved with more capital? Well yes, for some definition of "loads".
But annedotally I'd suggest that "most" are just bad ideas. Or perhaps more accurately "incomplete ideas".
To be a success business you need; A) a product B) a market for the product (ie people who would actually dip in their pockets) C) that you can reach via marketing D) that can afford the product.
The vast majority of business ideas have A, a few do B but its very rare that they consider C or D.
As techies we're all about A - build it and they will come. But a successful business needs all 4 - miss one out and you fail.
This sounds like a huge assumption being made here - as in, this is not as easy as it sounds.
We do this all the time so if I’m missing something I’m keen to hear it :)
Again, it's not a management report. You should use it for prioritisation. For example, all our go-to-market is very country-specific. So we can look at the payback period for different countries and compare how well they are performing, and that tell us which ones we should invest more into.
Every business should do it differently, based on which expenses are fixed or variable for them.
They had a massive churn issue around 3 months. They knew this was a cash cow that was printing money but someday it'd come to a end abruptly.
I suggested to them to offer 20% to their existing customers to switch to annual. They made ~$60k in a day and knew they'd have to refund if things went south before the annual contract ended. They were able to deploy the capital into marketing and explode.
In the end they had to shutdown but not before each founder had taken home +$250k and invested into legitimate means.
Here's a SaaS example: if it costs you $1000 to acquire a customer that pays you $100/month, the PBP is 10. That doesn't sound amazing. But you have options! If you give the customer a 20% discount to pay annually, they're now paying you ~$1000 upfront, for a PBP of 0. Tweak the numbers slightly and you can get a negative payback period. Suddenly your "capital inefficient" business has a big flywheel without the need for outside capital.
It's easy to think decreasing acquisition costs is what you need to do in the current market (and believe me, that's not a bad idea!), but that's the denominator. There's also a numerator - how much cash you bring in, and how quickly - that matters just as much. It's cash flow that matters, not profit.