News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Playing chicken with cat.jpg by bch on Thursday January 19, 2012 @11:18AM (#3485092)
There's no mention of what the filename was. Neither the basename, nor the extension. They say confidently "(It was a picture of a cat!)"
Re:Playing chicken with cat.jpg by mhartl on Thursday January 19, 2012 @11:23AM (#3485118)
They clarified this in a comment to the original post (http://37signals.com/svn/posts/3076-i-heard-you-like-numbers...):

    Razvan Tirboaca 12 Jan 12

        And a Basecamp user uploaded the 100,000,000th file
        (It was a picture of a cat!)

            Are you looking at your users photos?
And the response:

    Taylor 12 Jan 12

    Razvan, absolutely not. The file was named cat.jpg and
    that was logged, which was what we saw. We do not look 
    at user’s files.
Re:Playing chicken with cat.jpg by bch on Thursday January 19, 2012 @12:35PM (#3485543)
What does "cat" mean? Was the next file "bnc.jpg", "grep.jpg" -- even if it had something to do w/ felines -- was it in a dir of gfx of DNA visualizations, where the image would be a GATACA sequence or something? I don't know, but these are questions that immediately come to mind for me.
Re:Playing chicken with cat.jpg by mhartl on Thursday January 19, 2012 @03:17PM (#3486453)
Your response is a non sequitur. You stated

There's no mention of what the filename was. Neither the basename, nor the extension.

My comment merely quoted a 37signals employee giving the filename, both basename and extension. You can believe them or not, but they did explain the situation, and they explicitly denied looking at the image.

Re:Playing chicken with cat.jpg by biot on Thursday January 19, 2012 @12:27PM (#3485492)
And it couldn't have been a picture of a catalog, CAT construction machinery, someone named Catherine, etc.? I guess we have to take them for their word on this one.
Re:Playing chicken with cat.jpg by evan_ on Thursday January 19, 2012 @02:19PM (#3486125)
what if it was a picture of a catalog? The file was called cat.jpg so they said it was a picture of a cat. Maybe it was a catalog. They still said it was a picture of a cat.
Re:Playing chicken with cat.jpg by ufo on Thursday January 19, 2012 @09:22PM (#3487990)
This is the internez. Its perfectly fine to expect a random jpg to be a picture of a cat accompanied by the obligatory caption)
Re:Playing chicken with cat.jpg by tripzilch on Thursday January 19, 2012 @12:17PM (#3485426)
Further down in the comments they try to save themselves by saying "Of course we didn't look at it, it's just that the pic was called cat.jpg".

So, no, I don't believe them at all when they say they did never look at the file. They say--with confidence--it was a picture of a cat. Sorry but going from "cat.jpg" to such a conclusion is IMO quite a leap. It's just three letters, it could be a CAT scan, a screenshot of the Linux `cat` command, three DNA nucleotides, a picture of a tiger, something else named "cat" or something related to but not involving cats.

I don't know if I see a filename like that I'd say "It was called 'cat.jpg', so probably a picture of someone's cat." because it can be anything that somebody named "cat.jpg" for any number of reasons and I won't know for sure until I looked at it.

And even then, just them looking at the filenames is not right. Of course I understand that if it was `company-passwords.xls` or something more sensitive, they wouldn't have said anything. But already before they could judge whether the filename was sensitive or not, there really is no reason for why they needed to be looking at filenames in the first place!

Sure some admin can always go in as root and look at everything, but you don't need to tie the proverbial cat to the bacon, by putting the filenames right up someone's face who really has no business looking at them since they're just collecting statistics.

⊗