If you’re a reasonable person, yes. But when you’re not, all kinds of crazy patterns evolve.
E.g. a boss saying “I’m perfectly ok with functions that take more than 100 arguments.” (Compiler does not even support this.) and code being copy-pasted dozens of times being perfectly readable, but is a sink-hole when you refactor.
Clean Code (Martin’s book, and the movement in general) is my weapon when stubborn colleagues will not listen to reason. Sometimes they will listen to authority.
Just thinking out loud here, but isn't correctness(grammar and spelling) the only thing we all(mostly) agree on? For example, someone well versed with old English literature may consider Shakespeare easy to understand, but I certainly wouldn't. I think "speaks clearly, easy to understand" are just as subjective as our notions of clean/idiomatic/readable code.
What happens when half of your code uses functional patterns and the other half imperative/OO?
The same applies to code. It is not 100% deterministic metric, but it is relatively easy to argue and have a consensus upon.