It is only at the point of collision that the impulsive force is imparted to the other body.
See this Khan Academy video "Impulse and momentum dodgeball example" for detailed understanding: https://www.khanacademy.org/science/physics/linear-momentum/...
Also see article "Momentum Change and Impulse Connection" (note the Rebounding Collison section at the bottom) : https://www.physicsclassroom.com/class/momentum/Lesson-1/Mom...
Indeed, that was my point. Because "reversing of direction evaluates the numerator as (mv - (-mu)) = mv+mu along with the denominator t being made as small as possible thus resulting in a larger force" is incorrect for the same reason.
Also from my 2nd linked article;
Observe that each of the collisions above involve the rebound of a ball off a wall. Observe that the greater the rebound effect, the greater the acceleration, momentum change, and impulse. A rebound is a special type of collision involving a direction change in addition to a speed change. The result of the direction change is a large velocity change.
This reasoning would suggest that if you put two billiard balls next to each other and pull one of them away, conservation of momentum will result in the other rolling away in the opposite direction at the same speed. I've never seen that happen, and not just because I suck at billiards. When you pull the ball/your fist away, that changes the momentum of your body, not the other ball/your opponent's body that you're now no longer in contact with.