Re:The Pirate Bay's statement on PIPA/SOPA
by icebraining on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @10:00PM
(#3483020)
> you are taking the property of another party
Making a copy is not "taking".
Re:The Pirate Bay's statement on PIPA/SOPA
by andrewcamel on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @10:14PM
(#3483052)
icebraining: You copy something. You have taken it. It still exists where it originally did, but you still took it because you now have it in your possession. You can't keep justifying taking something without paying for it (stealing) with semantics.
Here's another argument for you. When a producer sells a piece of content, it is selling you a copy. You are paying for a copy. If you choose to not pay for a copy, you are effectively stealing a copy from the producer.
Regardless of whether you make a copy or remove the original, you are taking the property of another party without its permission to do so. That, by definition, is stealing. (see first entry in dictionary.com link)
Free PR makes up for lost sales, but would you choose 100 sales or 100 people that got your product for free, but might go tell other people about it?