News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why 10BASE-T1S Is the Missing Ethernet Link for Automotiv... by jeroenhd on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:36PM (#34828977)
Whatever connector you stick on the end, as long as it gains popularity someone will use it in weird ways. The second your start selling these connectors widely and for affordable prices, they're going to get reused.

See: USB over D-SUB, serial over RJ45, the wide range of proprietary protocols that cheap IDE cables were (and probably still are) use for today, and weird edge cases like reusing the sturdy DMX ports to power sex toys.

8P8C is fine for ethernet, it doesn't need replacing. Nobody uses it for telephony modems anymore and very rarely will an average user encounter a compatible plug that wasn't made for ethernet.

I'd rather see fringe use cases like serial over RJ45 use a better connector than to have to cut off, strip, and wire up a new connector for every new network appliance I'll buy in the next 10 years.

Re:Why 10BASE-T1S Is the Missing Ethernet Link for Automotiv... by elihu on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:37PM (#34829999)
Here's a Doepfer ribbon controller that uses a USB cable: https://doepfer.de/a198.htm

It's purely an analog device. Presumably they used USB because the cables are cheap, shielded, and have enough conductors for what they needed. (Probably ground plus signal wires for two linear pots and a pressure sensor.)

I hope they designed it so it doesn't fry something if you connect it to a real usb device, but I'm not inclined to try it.

Re:Why 10BASE-T1S Is the Missing Ethernet Link for Automotiv... by oasisbob on Thursday February 16, 2023 @10:17PM (#34830272)
> serial over RJ45

I'm almost certain that serial has been in common use on 8P8C longer than 100BaseT.

Personally, I'll stop believing in that connector when it stops being useful.

Re:Why 10BASE-T1S Is the Missing Ethernet Link for Automotiv... by oakwhiz on Friday February 17, 2023 @02:53AM (#34832034)
My one gripe with it is the missing ring indicator pin...
Re:Why 10BASE-T1S Is the Missing Ethernet Link for Automotiv... by SAI_Peregrinus on Friday February 17, 2023 @11:16AM (#34836494)
To be extra pedantic, it's serial with an "8P8C modular connector", not over RJ45. Sure, the physical connector is the same thing, but the RJ- standards define the uses of the various pins, not just the physical connector. RJ45, RJ49, and RJ61 all use the same "8P8C modular connector". RJ45S is for only one data line, with a programming resistor. RJ49C is an 8P8C carrying ISDN via NT1, RJ61 is four telephone lines on an 8P8C. There's no RJ standard for RS232 or for Ethernet at all!

Everyone (including me) still calls it RJ45 because "8P8C modular connector" is far too long a name.