News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Homebrew 4.0.0 by Athas on Thursday February 16, 2023 @11:42AM (#34821079)
> MacPorts is still alive and well (https://www.macports.org), and in-fact has basically all the same packages brew does.

I used macOS for a few years to try it out, and I found that Macports lacked many things I needed. Taking a quick look again, let's see...

* Oclgrind: No.

* Futhark: No.

* GHC: Yes! And updated to boot. (But I'd expect such major programs to be in any package system.)

* MLkit: No.

* hledger: Yes, although not the newest version.

* git-annex: Yes, but a rather old version.

* ispc: Yes, but again a rather old version.

The impression I got (which may be inaccurate) is that Macports has a long tail of older packages, but it does not have a lot of newer stuff. It is very easy and convenient to add packages to Homebrew (just a PR with a package definition in a Ruby DSL; most things are obvious), which I think is the main reason it has become successful.

Nowadays I suggest everyone just use Nix, of course. It's not as slick and has a tough barrier to entry, but it's built on fundamentally better principles than legacy package managers.

Re:Homebrew 4.0.0 by pseudalopex on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:29PM (#34827439)
MacPorts had more packages I wanted and fewer outdated packages the last time I compared them. Homebrew won the time before.

Is the Homebrew Ruby DSL much easier than the MacPorts Tcl DSL? I think the main reason Homebrew succeeded was it had binary packages before MacPorts. But a more familiar language helped probably.