News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What's more valuable: expert or broad knowledge i... by sph on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:04AM (#34816569)
More valuable for what? Value doesn't exist as an absolute.

Do you need a pianist? Get the world-class pianist.

Do you need an assistant? Get the one that knows the most things. If you have a particular need, you can always hire a specialist.

I find in these discussions people tends to say whatever career they have chosen is best. I am a generalist, so I am biased. Sure, sometimes one needs a world-class COBOL engineer, but pretty much any startup or small-mid business needs a software engineer that can wear many hats.

--

In simpler words. Which company sizes prefer which role?

* Startup: generalist (fewer hires, better time-to-market)

* Established tech company: specialist

* Established non-tech company: generalist (means smaller tech budget)

* Very large tech company/FAANG: generalist (in theory specialists are preferrable, but they use off-the-shelf or cutting edge tech that no one is truly specialised for).

* Very large non-tech company: specialist (to run their Oracle databases, and they have large budgets)

There are no comments on this comment yet.