This is, in fact, the main reason to oppose SOPA and PIPA. It gives the entertainment industry even more takedown powers (ads, financial instutions, domain names) and even less oversight.
You could argue that SOPA/PIPA isn't unreasonable if there were added protections of due process and significant penalties for abusing the system. But there isn't. If the DMCA is currently being abused, it stands to reason that SOPA/PIPA will be as well.
"Fair Use" has been damaged; it's much harder to use a snippet of something now without risking it being taken down.
Youtube's technical copyright protections are remarkable - I'm amazed that this model isn't a lot more popular throughout industry. Maybe Google needs to give this tech away for free and the tech community can show that they're trying to do something about rampant piracy. Except, I can't help feeling that a Youtube video isn't much of a problem. Even though I know the rights holders do see it as a problem, and happily block access to people in different territories or have content taken down.
I think it's a little harder to argue that DMCA doesn't work for tech companies given that it's been in effect for a long time and no-one has gone bankrupt as a result of it. However, some examples of incorrect takedowns that have resulted in loss of money for an artist would be very interesting.