News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by toomuchtodo on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:26AM (#34806060)
Sandy Munro's teardown of one of the first Model 3s (circa 2019) and his advice to Tesla in ~200 initial manufacturing improvements was integral in shifting their manufacturing strategy (and also led to the termination of the person who designed the body). A more recent 2021 teardown has a lot of praise for the latest build quality.

https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-model-3-sandy-munro-analyst-... ("Tesla and Munro have since communicated, with the auto veteran sending the electric car maker a list of over 200 pro bono suggestions that could improve the Model 3’s body, which he believed was over-engineered. Munro himself spoke with Elon Musk, who explained that the person responsible for the Model 3’s body design had been terminated. In response, Munro told the CEO that the response was “not fast enough,” since Tesla “never should have hired (the engineer)” in the first place.")

https://www.teslaoracle.com/2021/01/26/2021-tesla-model-3-sa... ("2021 Tesla Model 3 is as good as anything you could find out of Europe, says Sandy Munro")

Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by YeahNO on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:35PM (#34809375)
Not really fair to blame the engineer. Musk is the one who hired the engineer to lead the design of the Model 3, knowing he had no experience with vehicle manufacturing design. They wanted to "move fast and break things" like a tech company. It was an expensive learning process for Musk. A mistake he seems to repeatedly make.
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by adolph on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @03:14PM (#34809913)
Re:The giant die casts reshaping car manufacturing by YeahNO on Friday February 24, 2023 @11:30AM (#34926300)
Two different engineers, I am assuming Sandy Munro was disparaging Mr. Field. From your own Engadget link, you can clearly see that he had no vehicle manufacturing experience. Neither Apple, nor Segway produce automobiles, if that was unclear.

"Field, who previously worked at Apple and Segway, joined Tesla in 2013 to develop the company's next-generation EVs. In that sense, his mark on the company is hard to escape. However, there's a potential source of conflict. Elon Musk asked Field to handle both manufacturing and production in 2017, right as the Model 3 was becoming a practical reality. You may know what happened next. Tesla struggled to boost Model 3 production levels after relying too heavily on robots, and Musk took charge of manufacturing to be sure his company met its 5,000-a-week Model 3 production target. Field effectively lost a large part of his role."