News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by Laaas on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:07AM (#34803924)
Why do people still require PayPal in this day and age? Even if it's needed, why are your funds on there? I use Revolut, but make sure to keep more than enough as USDC to secure myself against arbitrary freezes.
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by colesantiago on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:10AM (#34803957)
Crypto, Bitcoin, USDC or any speculative vapourware tokens is absolutely not the answer here, please stop suggesting it.
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by rom-antics on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:20AM (#34804096)
Bitcoin maybe, but what's wrong with USDC? It's US-based, regulated and audited. Is this a case of guilt by association?
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by nicce on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:09PM (#34807019)
It is not government backed.
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by rom-antics on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:37PM (#34808504)
Keeping in mind the context of this thread, neither is Paypal.
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by tifadg1 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:19AM (#34804082)
one side is speculative vapourware tokens, the other side is prayers and hoping you're not flagged by algos.
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by krono on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:18AM (#34804065)
It can be part of an answer, but dismissing that route entirely and unfoundedly at that is just shortsighted
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by przeor on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:19AM (#34804094)
The telephone, the internet, and crypto share one thing in common. Each technology improves on the next in terms of its ability to facilitate fraud. As such, I was initially a crypto skeptic, but after studying some of the more interesting crypto projects, I have come to realization world must evolve
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by tirpen on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @09:26AM (#34804184)
Yes, if you only look at the downsides, the three inventions might be kind of comparable like that. The difference is of course that the first two have beneficial uses as well.
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by boring_twenties on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:02PM (#34806894)
This very post is a perfect example of the benefits of decentralized, peer to peer electronic cash.
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by przeor on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:22AM (#34815992)
I know thousands of people who benefited from crypto, many individually. 99% of them are outside USA
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by Laaas on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @10:55AM (#34805509)
USDC is not speculative? It's a stablecoin. Gold would also be a solution but its illiquidity makes it impractical.
Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by logicalmonster on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:26PM (#34807321)
Are you the emperor of the world that has the right to tell people what to do?

Crypto solves some of the specific problems that people repeatedly have dealing with mega-corporations and/or fiat currencies.

HackerNews has the collective memory of a goldfish when it comes to crypto. We constantly see peoples' money being stolen and messed with, but then a smug elitist comes out of nowhere and says "Well, ackshually, there's no possible use case for crypto." Absolutely disgusting that we cannot learn from history.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by colesantiago on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:05PM (#34807979)
> Crypto solves some of the specific problems that people repeatedly have dealing with mega-corporations and/or fiat currencies.

Which are?

> We constantly see peoples' money being stolen and messed with, but then a smug elitist comes out of nowhere and says "Well, ackshually, there's no possible use case for crypto."

Yes, with the same 'smug elitists' building, funding crypto exchanges built as a giant ponzi scheme that inevitably crashes and burns to the ground and lose everyone's money in the process.

Maybe it isn't a good idea to try and speedrun all the asset bubbles of financial history.

> Absolutely disgusting that we cannot learn from history.

Tulip Mania (1634)

The South Sea Bubble (1720)

Comic book speculation bubble (1985-1993)

Beanie Babies Bubble (2000)

They all end in the same way.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by logicalmonster on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @01:38PM (#34808514)
I notice you didn't respond to my question about whether or not you're the emperor of the world who has the right to tell people what to do. Please clarify if you are or are not. I certainly wouldn't want to disrespect his or her majesty.

> Which are?

You are literally responding in a thread about money being allegedly stolen from a non-profit by a mega-corporation.

Are you pretending to not see a possible use-case for crypto in any arc of this story?

Sad! Many such cases.

> Yes, with the same 'smug elitists' building, funding crypto exchanges built as a giant ponzi scheme that inevitably crashes and burns to the ground and lose everyone's money in the process.

The problems with centralized exchanges are not problems with crypto in and of itself. The crypto way of thinking about exchanges is actually "Not your keys, not your coins".

> Maybe it isn't a good idea to try and speedrun all the asset bubbles of financial history.

There's many reasonable debates and disagreements about how you define crypto and what it currently is and what it will be, but there's significant qualitative differences between crypto and these other examples.

For instance, a farmer can grow more tulips and flood the market. Or a tulip easily ages and dries out and has no value. But there can only ever be 21 million Bitcoins, and they exist forever.

A beanie baby sort of just sits on a shelf, collecting dust, and silently judging you. But crypto has amazing possible real world utility without even thinking about its value as money, such as being a decentralized programmable tool.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by colesantiago on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @08:24PM (#34813687)
> I notice you didn't respond to my question about whether or not you're the emperor of the world who has the right to tell people what to do.

Because this is irrelevant.

> You are literally responding in a thread about money being allegedly stolen from a non-profit by a mega-corporation.

Are you pretending to not see a possible use-case for crypto in any arc of this story?

Sad! Many such cases.

Yes, the many such great usecases being, enabling ransomware, speculation, scams and rugpulls and losing your money due to volatility. Any usecases crypto tries to provide or replace is never any better than the current financial system.

We have UPI which launched in 2016 with already over hundreds of millions of active users using it for P2P payments, a goal that Bitcoin was supposed to achieve but completely failed in doing so.

Anything Bitcoin can do, the current financial system can do it already or even better, safer with less energy needed.

No matter how you dress it up, Bitcoin and all the other cryptos have no legitimate usecase whatsoever.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by logicalmonster on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:38PM (#34815092)
> Because this is irrelevant.

I made the point in a bit of a flippant way, but the strong authoritarian leanings of the people who dislike crypto are not an irrelevant point to me. Why are the people who seem to like telling others what to do the most also the ones who hate crypto the most? This pattern really activates my almonds.

> Any usecases crypto tries to provide or replace is never any better than the current financial system. We have UPI which launched in 2016 with already over hundreds of millions of active users using it for P2P payments, a goal that Bitcoin was supposed to achieve but completely failed in doing so. Anything Bitcoin can do, the current financial system can do it already or even better, safer with less energy needed. No matter how you dress it up, Bitcoin and all the other cryptos have no legitimate usecase whatsoever.

1) Once again, you're literally responding to a story where a non-profit allegedly got their money stolen by a mega-corporation. How did the current financial system protect them? (even if this case isn't accurate, you could substitute many other news cases. Just search for "paypal stole" in HackerNews for a pile of examples, just from one company)

2) I assume you're referring to India's UPI. I'm sure that this kind of financial infrastructure works phenomenally, just until the point that you're a political adversary and the government decides that it wants to mess with your ability to transact to stifle your voice. For people on society's margins who speak inconvenient truths, crypto's inability to easily get shut down is an advantage that the existing financial infrastructure cannot offer.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by colesantiago on Thursday February 16, 2023 @01:18AM (#34815694)
1) The money is not actually 'stolen' this is an extreme exaggeration it's still in PayPal and just held for 180 days.

> For people on society's margins who speak inconvenient truths, crypto's inability to easily get shut down is an advantage that the existing financial infrastructure cannot offer.

2) You mean like criminals, drug dealers? As I can only see this group being on 'the margins of society' being empowered by crypto. Just because one system is imperfect, does not mean you replace it with a completely worse system that doesn't work for anybody.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by logicalmonster on Thursday February 16, 2023 @02:19PM (#34824243)
> 1) The money is not actually 'stolen' this is an extreme exaggeration it's still in PayPal and just held for 180 days.

Holy Gaslighting Batman, this is on another level.

Imagine what you'd think if somebody grabbed something you needed and while he was running down the street, told you that it's not stolen because he pinky swears to give it back in half a year. The belief that it might be returned later is immaterial to the concept of theft. If you can't do what you want with your own property, is it not stolen?

You keep talking about being against criminals, but are willfully ignoring a theft that's right in front of you.

> 2) You mean like criminals, drug dealers? As I can only see this group being on 'the margins of society' being empowered by crypto. Just because one system is imperfect, does not mean you replace it with a completely worse system that doesn't work for anybody.

Whenever governments want to enact something dystopian, they always justify it by claiming that it's going to fight the worst person they can think of to get popular sentiment on their side: like terrorists and murderers. Those kinds of criminals are very easy to spot.

But what happens when governments declare it a crime to speak out against the government?Those people are also labeled criminals, and have their funding seized.

This isn't a theoretical discussion: this happens every time authoritarians take power. They of course seize any funds from protestors to limit any political opposition. This isn't even limited to some 3rd world countries, but also happens in prosperous Western countries.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by colesantiago on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:51PM (#34829134)
You're the only person in this thread strawmanning and talking about the funds being 'stolen' which is an exaggeration and is completely false. The correct term that PayPal has done is that they froze the account and it's held for 180 days.

So it isn't really theft at all if PayPal still holds the funds. If the funds are completely out of PayPal's hands and not in your account, then it is stolen.

In fact, should we compare to crypto sector, once you money is stolen or sent to the wrong address, there is NOBODY you can ask to get your money back, ever.

This is what I mean by you trying to augment or replace the current financial system with an even worse completely libertarian and utopianist system and whatever you say on 'dystopian governments' doesn't change this fact.

Even if we take your 'dystopian governments' view, when they control the crypto exchanges, there will be no way you can swap or or anyone to accept your worthless magic beans to fiat when this will be made illegal.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by logicalmonster on Friday February 17, 2023 @07:20AM (#34833783)
> You're the only person in this thread strawmanning and talking about the funds being 'stolen' which is an exaggeration and is completely false.

We apparently have an irreconcilable disagreement about the nature of theft and I don't think there's any common ground to discuss this further. I sincerely hope you never get stolen from in this manner. If some mega-corporation locked up your needed funds for 180 days though, I doubt that you'd be contorting yourself trying to justify why it's not actually theft.

> Even if we take your 'dystopian governments' view, when they control the crypto exchanges, there will be no way you can swap or or anyone to accept your worthless magic beans to fiat when this will be made illegal.

1) Who said anything about trading crypto for fiat? The purpose of money is to trade for goods and services. If crypto exchanges are shut down, you can still trade directly with other people. (This I think is what puts self-righteous authoritarians in a tizzy: there's no way to perfectly control other people with crypto.)

2) I'm not sure what magic beans you're referring to. Are you referring to the magic beans that are backed up by nothing and which are printed indefinitely?

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by colesantiago on Friday February 17, 2023 @06:54PM (#34842235)
Who do you hold accountable when your crypto funds get lost?

Who do you go to when your crypto funds go to the wrong address?

Or more commonly, Who do you go to when your crypto funds are drained from your wallet?

We both know you cannot go to anybody ever in any situation and is the reason why crypto is a failure especially as a currency, payments and for everything else.

At least we know the funds are frozen and held by PayPal (which we can hold accountable) and not some shady exchange that went offline, or some random person's wallet address.

So once again, you have proposed a monumentally worse system that nobody or any business wants to use or deal with in the real world, and the erratic crypto volatility wouldn't help the situation either should such a bad situation happen.

> If crypto exchanges are shut down, you can still trade directly with other people.

Many have tried this with crypto and this has completely failed as unrealistic at any scale.

The government won't accept your crypto / magic beans as a way to pay your taxes. They won't accept it now, and they won't accept it when the crypto exchanges are shutdown.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by logicalmonster on Saturday February 18, 2023 @01:08PM (#34849304)
> Who do you hold accountable when your crypto funds get lost? Who do you go to when your crypto funds go to the wrong address?

> Many have tried this with crypto and this has completely failed as unrealistic at any scale.

1) I know it's scary, but living with personal responsibility can be a thing that some people actually want.

2) We're extremely early into the invention of cryptocurrencies. Bitcoin is only about 14 years old. Better interfaces and best practices for how these things are handled and moved around are developing. You remind me of somebody being around in say 1978, seeing the simple computers of the day, and remarking that there's no practical use for normal people having a computer because you think that they currently suck and cannot conceive of them improving.

3) Look at human economic history. It took humans in some cases hundreds of years to figure out what we might see as best practices for new accounting concepts or technologies. Some kind of basic ledger system with tablets, sticks, or other implements proving that a tax payment or loan was made took a long time to figure out. Humans didn't know how to handle silver coins initially, it took time to figure out that hey had to put ridges on gold/silver coins to prevent certain people from clipping chunks off them. Fiat has been around a while and many humans still haven't made the connection between printing money and inflation directly robbing them. Is it any surprise that crypto isn't completely developed just 14 years in?

> nobody or any business wants to use or deal with in the real world

Do you not notice an inherent contradiction in what you're saying: why would you need to block exchanges if nobody wants to use it in the real world?

> The government won't accept your crypto / magic beans as a way to pay your taxes.

"Use fiat. Not necessarily because you think it has the best attributes for you, but because men with guns will throw you in a metal cage if you do not."

Not the most persuasive argument for me, sorry.

Re:Ask HN: Our nonprofit got shut down by PayPal. Help? by colesantiago on Saturday February 18, 2023 @02:42PM (#34850296)
> 1) I know it's scary, but living with personal responsibility can be a thing that some people actually want.

Right, so it's the OP's fault if you get your wallet randomly drained by hackers and you admit that once a bad actor drains your funds you cannot retrieve them again. This is really helpful for the OP.

> 2) We're extremely early into the invention of cryptocurrencies. Bitcoin is only about 14 years old.

It is not early days at all. Repeating this meaningless cultish incantation doesn't mean or do anything. There are other payment systems that I have mentioned that are proven to be WAY better than crypto.

To be on topic to help the OP, all your arguments have further convinced me that crypto is absolutely NOT the answer to help this person should a situation like this happen.

I don't think anybody would want to use a system that has no fraud control, isn't regulated and doesn't protect their funds.

It seems to me you feel that we need to waste almost 12BN in crypto scams, rugpulls and ransomware just to build the future of finance without need for the state.

Have you stopped to consider that what crypto might be building is, a much much MUCH worse system that what is currently marketed towards victims?

> Why would you need to block exchanges if nobody wants to use it in the real world?

As I said before, the only use case in all of this is price speculation and the exchanges facilitate this and also harbour the selling of illegal securities. There is no other legitimate use case.

And after FTX, there is no convincing anyone anymore and you're completely losing a very very uphill battle and resorting to fanciful, loony pie-in-the-sky libertarian arguments.

It's more of a case of current system already uses fiat and it works better than what crypto is trying to replace.