News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I'm a Pirate by njs12345 on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @07:57AM (#3479380)
What's the difference? In both cases the pirate is deriving an economic benefit without directly causing an economic cost.
Re:Why I'm a Pirate by njs12345 on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @08:32AM (#3479525)
If the pirate derives benefit from it but less benefit than the price and thus does not consume, then there is a deadweight loss. In this case, piracy provides a net benefit to society.

(Studies have shown that the sales-displacing effect of piracy in music ranges from 42% to no effect at all[1]. If all piracy could be prevented, that's an awfully large deadweight loss)

[1] http://www.heinz.cmu.edu/~rtelang/SmithTelang.pdf

Re:Why I'm a Pirate by olavk on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @08:18AM (#3479467)
If the pirate is enjoying the music, then clearly the pirate would be willing to pay something more than nothing to hear the music, if piracy were not easily avaliable.
Re:Why I'm a Pirate by rdtsc on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @09:17AM (#3479738)
> be willing to pay something more than nothing to hear the music.

In this case $0 or even a negative value amount is what you can plug into something. Why? Think about artists that tried pay-what-you-want model. A lot of people pay $0. Some pay $0.10. But a lot pay $0.

However, what they pay with is with their time and attention.

I used to know someone who managed a movie theater. He would sneak us into movies quite often. Good and bad. And quite often after coming out of the movie I felt like wanting "my free back".

Let's say an artist is unknown and I am a customer that has quite a few connection ( a blog with a large following perhaps ). Then what would make sense is for me to pay a negative amount ( the artist would pay me to spend my time listening to his new cool record in the hopes that I might spread the news about it ).

Re:Why I'm a Pirate by moozilla on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @08:15PM (#3482745)
> Think about artists that tried pay-what-you-want model. A lot of people pay $0. Some pay $0.10. But a lot pay $0.

FWIW, the only album I've paid for in years was a pay-what-you-want deal. I paid something like $3. Which was all that was left in my bank account after I paid my rent and bought groceries for that month - I'm a college student.

Re:Why I'm a Pirate by egil on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @08:27AM (#3479510)
Of course, but that implies that it is possible to pay for it. The copyright holders must adapt business models so potential customers can pay for a product they want, not some inferior DRM that hurts the customer. As long as piracy gives potential customers the best product, the incentive to pay is lost.
Re:Why I'm a Pirate by al_james on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @08:17AM (#3479466)
There is an economic cost. If even one person pirates a digital work who WOULD have paid for it had pirating not been an option, it causes a cost to the producer of the media. So there is a real cost.
Re:Why I'm a Pirate by drcube on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @09:33AM (#3479814)
And if one person buys a digital work due to piracy who otherwise would not have even known the artist existed, there is a benefit.

Do you have any evidence that the costs outweigh the benefits?

Re:Why I'm a Pirate by nirvdrum on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @10:22AM (#3480087)
Who is pirating works from artists they've never heard of? Everyone I know who pirates stuff is actively looking for something.
Re:Why I'm a Pirate by burgerbrain on Wednesday January 18, 2012 @11:15AM (#3480384)
Everybody I know... They download in bulk and sift through it looking for things they like.

And without exception, all of those "pirates" that I know have much larger legal bluray and record collections than I do.