This is about as far as they can go, and tellingly this is the first time that I can remember them using their homepage for such a call to action.
Expecting them to go dark for 24 hours is just naïve.
Their shareholders will have much more to worry about if SOPA passes. Plus, Google being completely down in protest for a day would be a huge PR win; it would make those that stayed up and running look ridiculous. Wikipedia's approach is the strongest and most likely to actually sway people into action while Google's will be largely ignored by the public.
I'm actually thoroughly thrilled with what they did, when I visited the main search page the blacked out Google logo was actually psychologically shocking for me, enough to make me click it to find out why (that black box acts like a visual sink attracting me).
Think of the crazy amount of people that hit that main search page. This plus Wikipedia's complete blackout will seriously make some movement.
This is more than just a doodle. And it's a day long event at a ton of websites. People will notice the doodle. They'll notice that wikipedia is down. They'll notice Wordpress' page. They'll notice the front page of Huffington Post. In the context of everything that's happening today, people will perk up.
Firstly - the time involved, 2nd - email is free, 3rd - its easier.