News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by bayindirh on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:35AM (#34774718)
Making low noise, highly efficient, actively cooled heat exchangers is hard. Also, even if you use ARM processors, you use a lot of them, again creating a lot of heat.

So at the end, you either need much more heat exchangers, make some noise, reduce capacity or invent better cooling tech.

So, changing the law is not enough. You need to motivate right people to innovate, too.

Also, on US; good luck trying to change their behaviors through law. This is why companies have lobbyists.

Disclosure: HPC admin sitting on top of a datacenter.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by ryanianian on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:36AM (#34774753)
Making things very expensive is precisely how to motivate people to innovate.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by robertlagrant on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:38AM (#34774788)
It's one of the worst ways. But it is a way.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by notacoward on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:45AM (#34774934)
So what's a better way, when persuasion and appeals to conscience have already failed? Surely you don't suggest that raw force is better.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by robertlagrant on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:48AM (#34775999)
I was replying to this:

> Making things very expensive is precisely how to motivate people to innovate.

That statement has no caveats around persuasion and appeals to conscience.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by notacoward on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:52PM (#34778259)
If it doesn't then it's drifting off topic, which I don't actually think was your intent, but let's follow along a bit anyway. What does motivate people to innovate? Obviously one motivation is internal, basically curiosity (which someone not trying to be so argumentative might have considered equivalent to persuasion). And another is profit. But what if a innovation in a particular area would only be necessary to maintain profitability, because current methods are already cheaper but damaging (e.g. environment) or otherwise unacceptable (e.g. privacy)? Then we're back to making that activity as it is currently done more expensive.

"That's a bad way to motivate innovation" still begs the question of what would actually be better in the real world for cases where sufficient motivation is currently lacking. The case where no "spur" is needed isn't even interesting in this context.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by robertlagrant on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:04PM (#34778491)
You're welcome to retroactively apply a test for whether you find something interesting. I wasn't talking in that context, though.

I just took the statement as written and wrote a brief comment on it, without reading anything else into it.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by notacoward on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:08PM (#34778550)
> I wasn't talking in that context, though.

Yes, you were, whether you acknowledge it or not. You can't just ignore the existing context and expect everyone to follow you into a new one that you supposedly created out of nowhere. That's not only the height of hubris, but it's also not how curious conversation works. Please see the guidelines.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by DonHopkins on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:33PM (#34778999)
Although his rhetorical gymnastics attempting to dodge and avoid answering those obvious questions are certainly telling and amusing, and he helps make your point by ignoring the context and not being willing to address your straightforward questions.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by robertlagrant on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:04PM (#34779514)
I didn't create a new context; doing so would not have been the height of hubris; and I didn't expect people to follow me, other than in the most basic (or so I thought) comprehension sense. You and DonHopkins are the only ones behaving badly enough to be accused of annihilating curious conversation. My few words cannot be accused of that.

I have seen the guidelines, and nowhere do I see DonHopkins' mouth-frothing or your arbitrary rule-setting there.

I appreciate that now you've read my comment in its correct context (that of the previous comment) you understand it and aren't trying to say anything in response other than some brand new iron laws of conversation and DonHopkins' gossipy nastiness, as that hopefully means you've at least accepted it for what it is. A simple truthful statement, designed to modify the predecessor which was not, in my opinion, sufficiently caveated.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by bastawhiz on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:47AM (#34774966)
No, it's just shifting the cost of dealing with waste (pollution, sound) back to the producer rather than allowing them to make it someone else's problem. The cost isn't high, it's what it needs to be to run the operation in a way that's agreeable to the everyone in the area.

If you don't want to operate a business that deals with those costs, move or don't build a data center.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by notdonspaulding on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:18AM (#34775488)
I'm not the GP, but I agree with this stance. But the specific policy proposed really matters if this is your goal. Politicians often want to write very narrow regulations which are intended to tweak some small behavior by some specific business they find distasteful (or politically desirable to modify). So they play whack-a-mole with problems like this by writing policies that look like: "in Zone 5, businesses operating as data centers must operate cooling equipment that does not increase ambient noise levels above X decibels within Y meters of their property. "

This kind of policy does not accomplish the cost-shifting you talk about. Rather, a cost-shifting policy looks like: "in Maricopa county, a business may make as much noise as it likes, but must pay fees to the owner of any plot of land which has its ambient noise levels raised in the amount of $X per Y decibels per minute per square meter experiencing increased noise. "

I'm not aware of much regulation in the latter vein, at least not where I live. But it has the advantage of cost shifting, from ANY business, to those affected by the negative externality. That reinternalizes the cost without hampering freedom of businesses to operate in whatever way most efficiently accomplishes their goals, and helps C-suite execs see the true cost of their operations, which incentivizes them to innovate that cost away. It's also not specific to the cause of the noise, so church bells pay the same as the data center which pays the same as the glass factory which pays the same as the concert venue.

My $0.02 anyway.

Vote notdonspaulding 2024!

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by robertlagrant on Monday February 13, 2023 @03:10PM (#34779629)
I think the reason such broad brush stroke laws aren't made is probably partly a lack of system thinking, but also partly a result of it. If you try and monetise church bells, people will oppose it. Easier to monetise the evil corporations.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by DonHopkins on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:01AM (#34775220)
Heaven forbid that raising taxes on sprawling mega-corporations might accidentally pay for infrastructure and education and housing and health care.

Think of all the poor libertarian children living in their mother's basements jacking off to Ayn Rand books whose delicate feelings and incel ideologies will be hurt!

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by incone123 on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:10AM (#34775357)
Not all Rand fans live in basements. Larry Ellison is one, and a few other famous names are too. Nothing against your general point about public services though.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by DonHopkins on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:19AM (#34775494)
Yet the grown up ones still act like angry spoiled incel teenaged boys who don't know the price of a bar of soap, like Elon Musk as an archetypical example. Which is my point exactly.

Anyone who hasn't grown out of being a foaming-at-the-mouth libertarian after they've reached puberty and moved out of their mother's basement is suffering from arrested development and a nihilistic lack of empathy for their fellow human beings.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by robertlagrant on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:30AM (#34775687)
The only person angry and foaming at the mouth appears to be you.

If you're this aggressive based just on what I said then it's worth considering if you also interpret various other very normal things people say in the worst way possible, and the problem is mostly in your own perception. If so: don't be a libertarian, and get help.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by DonHopkins on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:38AM (#34775834)
It seems you need to get help to explain what to do after persuasion and appeals to conscience have already failed, if not simply making it too expensive to not innovate with taxes and regulations. As notacoward asked: surely you don't suggest that raw force is better? Or do you have a better and proven solution? Go reply to his question above that you're pointedly ignoring.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by robertlagrant on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:45AM (#34775945)
I was replying to this:

> Making things very expensive is precisely how to motivate people to innovate.

I don't think that is the best way to innovate. The ability to make money is the best way.

> that you're pointedly ignoring.

I don't really understand the mentality of someone who would write this, as though someone can ignore something in piecemeal asynchronous communication.

I also don't understand the archaic phrasing, and while I feel I shouldn't have to say this, but I am not at an 18th century finishing school and you are not my headmistress.

Again, don't be a libertarian, and get help. You don't have to do this alone.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by notacoward on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:56PM (#34778339)
> The ability to make money is the best way.

Do you really mean to ignore or dismiss the relationship between "ability to make money" and "things becoming more expensive"? That's not going to work here. Raise your game.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by robertlagrant on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:21AM (#34775537)
I'm not sure what you're talking about. I'm saying in general it's the worst way. Not scoped to this. And it's nothing to do with taxes being bad or good.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by ilyt on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:04PM (#34776331)
Or just move elsewhere where it isn't a problem. Hell, they shouldn't be built near the housing in the first place but someone probably lobbied their way into it...
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by RC_ITR on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:37AM (#34774778)
I think the implication is that you do noise abatement on the AC units (i.e. earthen berms, better site planning, etc.).
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by blamazon on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:43AM (#34774894)
As you pointed out, even just dirt works. Noise abatement is done for urban freeways all the time, without changing the trucks, cars, road surface, et cetera.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by reaperducer on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:18AM (#34775487)
Noise abatement is done for urban freeways all the time, without changing the trucks, cars, road surface, et cetera.

One of the reasons the Kennedy Expressway in downtown Chicago is zoned for skyscrapers on both sides is to block the traffic noise from getting into the rest of the area.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by RC_ITR on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:24PM (#34780786)
Dallas does the same thing with 75 and it's so wild because it seems like you're in an intensely urban area for miles, but really it's a wall of 10-15 story buildings surrounded by single family homes.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by duped on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:08PM (#34776397)
That's not true at all, automobiles and road surfaces are engineered for their acoustics in addition to noise abatement along roadways. Otherwise we wouldn't require mufflers or design better performing asphalt/cement mixtures and groove patterns that balance friction and noise.

And even with all of that it's not great.

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by blamazon on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:20PM (#34776630)
To make my statement more precise, I know what you're saying is true but what I mean is, in a three month span one can put noise abatement panels along a freeway, in say, Charlotte North Carolina. (Just to be optimistic in this hypothetical) Three months isn't enough time to propagate effects from the long term changes that you correctly mentioned are responsible for reducing auto noise on a larger scale, and those panels aren't going to make the sound go away entirely, but they will abate the noise on the other side. That's what I'm saying is happening all the time and is analogous to the conditions in the article which seem to be newly constructed data centers. Of course there will be changes over time inside the data centers that make them more efficient and whatnot, but if there's a nearby residential zone when a new one is being built, just put some abatement into the site design. That takes no R&D, but it does take more capital.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by rhacker on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:59AM (#34775190)
What about blocking the sound from getting out into the world
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by DonHopkins on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:10AM (#34775363)
Blocking the press coverage is more efficient.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by cm2187 on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:34AM (#34775748)
Or don't build datacentres in populated areas, it's not a few km will matter in term of latency.
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by ilyt on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:05PM (#34776344)
But think about that 5 minutes extra commute datacenter workers would need to have! /s
Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by tonyarkles on Monday February 13, 2023 @02:05PM (#34778517)
While it's not data centres, locally we've had this issue but flipped on its head a bit: big electrical facilities were built out 5 minutes out of town on farmland... and then the city grew and now has critical electrical facilities right in the middle of residential areas.

Edit: funny enough, we had a similar situation with a rural gun range. In that case, at least, when they built the suburban neighbourhood next door the buyers did have a clause in the purchase contract that acknowledged that they were purchasing property next to an existing range and that there would be noise. They were generally fine with it until the national police force started renting the range and doing full-auto practice on Saturday mornings :D

Re:Some data centers are noisy neighbors by bayindirh on Tuesday February 14, 2023 @01:36AM (#34786195)
It's not a matter of latency, or travel time as some of the latter comments mention (albeit sarcastically).

It's mostly about power. You can't just select a place and say "I want 5MW (or 10MW) of electricity, just here".

Fiber is thin, easy to lay down and flexible. Power cables are not. Also power planning is apparently hard.