News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Go claims telemetry objectors arguing in bad faith and vi... by layer8 on Monday February 13, 2023 @09:55AM (#34774126)
The checkbox being pre-checked is still not legal in some countries, exactly because it favors the non privacy protecting option.
Re:Go claims telemetry objectors arguing in bad faith and vi... by alkonaut on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:03AM (#34774248)
> The checkbox being pre-checked is still not legal in some countries exactly because it favors the non privacy protecting option

I think you are confusing this with systems that gather any PII, and regulations such as the GDPR and similar. This is about collecting data without any PII so any privacy regulation wouldn't apply here.

Re:Go claims telemetry objectors arguing in bad faith and vi... by layer8 on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:12AM (#34774354)
If the telemetry data is associated with the IP or contains anything that can be used to identify or track the particular Go installation (similar to a browser fingerprint), then it can be considered PII.
Re:Go claims telemetry objectors arguing in bad faith and vi... by alkonaut on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:14AM (#34774383)
Of course. But then it's not "anonymous usage statistics" at all is it?
Re:Go claims telemetry objectors arguing in bad faith and vi... by layer8 on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:18AM (#34774463)
I don’t know how they can collect useful statistics when they cannot distinguish between 1000 invocations by the same user/environment vs. one invocation by 1000 different users/environments. And when they can distinguish, then that tracking is prone to fall under personal data processing.
Re:Go claims telemetry objectors arguing in bad faith and vi... by alkonaut on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:29AM (#34774593)
Most off the shelf systems work with random pseudonyms: You generate a unique random number and store it only on the end user's system. Then you tag each data value with the random id one. These random identifiers do not count as PII so long as it is not possible to tie them to a real identity. So while you are of course required to follow data processing regulations, pseudonymous usage statistics with random identifiers is not against any regulation I know about at least. The lifespan of the pseudonym can be as long or short as you want e.g. last one session, one week, one version etc. But even when completely persistent, they will not constitute PII.
Re:Go claims telemetry objectors arguing in bad faith and vi... by joshuamorton on Monday February 13, 2023 @12:24PM (#34776715)
You should read the proposal. It collects a batch of per user statistics (counters).

So there is no issue of per-invocation tracking.