Back in the Ford era, it was at least commonly understood common sense that people need to be able to afford products. Today? The people are held poor so that they can't afford to strike, much less openly revolt, and nickeled-and-dimed by the credit industry.
The advice from Ramsey and friends makes sense and is objectively the best thing people can do, but at the same time its messaging is clear: miss out on the fun everyone else has achieved by debt.
> Today? The people are held poor so that they can't afford to strike, much less openly revolt, and nickeled-and-dimed by the credit industry.
I think it's less that they're held so "poor" (i.e. not having access to a lot of cash) as that they are so completely effectively barred from any kind of sustenance outside of the Debt System that striking would mean the total abandonment of any kind of life they're used to. A real revolution would mean complete blockage from almost every public space and service--unlike the past, there's not anywhere for you to go if you're at odds with the banking system. You'll starve, or you'll be tracked and thrown in jail to suffer the wrath of the stupid, uncivilized drug-addicted gangs. There's not even food in the lands surrounding the towns and cities, it's all single-crop cash yields that get exported.
People are also very carefully manipulated (not necessarily deliberately--it's just the net result of all aggregate manipulation) to be extremely suspicious and cautious of anything that would upset the life they're used to. If you talk to anyone above $140k/year household aggregate about the possibility of living 2-3 families in one home or never travelling by air again they look at you like you're speaking a foreign language.
The system is headed for feudalism, where majority of the population will never own land/home, and will have lesser rights than those that do.
People who think this is a fantasy, should check what percentage of the population can afford a lawyer. it's like 20-30% tops
On the whole, the problem isn't that people are buying $70k trucks and escalades that's keeping them poor. It's not having enough income.
The difference personally between $70k and $90k is massive and the difference between $90k and $120k is massive. That's the difference between underfunding my retirement and no savings and still being fairly tight on fun money, and having all of those things and still being able to pay that surprise $2k vet bill and just not save as much that month.
And I pay less to own than I did to rent, in a nicer house, and I'm building equity when I do it.
Was there an attitude change towards savings/etc there too? Sure. But like, the biggest difference was just having more money. You can't save when you don't have money coming in.
And at $70k I was making more than the median family with kids. People have to make do with a lot less than that. And that becomes "can't fix the car" or "can't afford to go to the hospital" or "kids don't eat breakfast" at the bottom end. $40k with kids is poverty, and that's an awful lot of people. When your shitty insurance drops you a $40k bill for a weekend in the hospital you're not paying that and it will take the rest of your finances with it.
It comes off as entitled when you tell people they're doing it wrong, when the overwhelming majority of people in the economy are losing. The middle-class lifestyle as we have come to know it basically requires you be in the top 10% of income earners in your local economy. At some point it's a society-wide problem, people respond to the incentives you give them as best they can with the resources they have. But a talk-show host saying "just buy more money" isn't going to fix those social-level problems. The problem isn't people, and if your system requires magical rational-actors who will wageslave for 50 years without the occasional vacation or other nicety and die penniless in retirement after cutting social security, then your system is going to fail.
At a societal level, there is no "one weird trick from a talk-show host" to bypass the incentives we've set up or vastly increase the amount of resources any one person is allocated. Well, crime I guess.
> The middle-class lifestyle as we have come to know it basically requires you be in the top 10% of income earners in your local economy.
Absolutely true. I've found that to not worry about any of (health, retirement, surprise bills, vehicles, housing) you need about $100k/year post-tax, and that's in a heartland state with "low" COL.
> The problem isn't people, and if your system requires magical rational-actors who will wageslave for 50 years without the occasional vacation or other nicety and die penniless in retirement after cutting social security, then your system is going to fail.
Amusingly, this is one of the reasons I'm not too worried about the inevitability of the system crashing. The current system is bound for failure. It's practically designed to fail. Once it fails, something will have to take its place. I think there's just enough civilizational inertia that the US isn't headed for total anarchy, as is always a risk for less-developed places when the currency and the food importation falls through.
I mean I just feel that on average you get what you incentivize. Yeah for any one person, advice can help them break the average but on the whole people respond how the system has encouraged them to respond. It's the same as the critique people make about communism... if your system requires people to go against human nature, it's not going to work. Individuals may, but on the whole, humans are gonna act like humans. Implying that people are doing it wrong personally because they're failing in a system in which the overwhelming majority of people are failing becomes personally offensive and that's why people react negatively.
The crushing underlying fact of american society is that the middle class isn't middle anymore, probably over half of people are working-poor at this point and there's really only a handful of middle-class left in america (in the "own a house, go on vacation once in a while, not worry about surprise bills" sense). And maybe that's part of why people react viscerally negatively to it too... nobody wants to think of themselves as lower-class and that's rubbed in your face when Ramsey tells them to live within their means. You can't afford that vacation and neither can your friends, you're all wage-slaves, just like 90% of america. Back onto your treadmill, hamster.
Building local communities and building for resiliency is really important, as another commenter was discussing. I have this early 80s tractor that I inherited from my grandparents, it's nothing special but it's had very little wear since my grandpa got alzheimers soon after and they started having it mowed by a service, and it's had some basic preventative maintenance (oil changes once a decade, new tires, etc) and I've found myself thinking that I probably should keep it around even if I upgrade to something newer. Because it's got a briggs+stratton 2-cyl boxer motor on a steel frame and it's going to be something I can find parts for forever and repair it if it comes down to it, and that's kind of a novelty in a world of cheap throwaway junk. Same for appliances, I have old 90s washer+dryer that came with the house and it's nothing particularly special, it's worn out and needs at least a couple hundred bucks of parts each, but I hear nothing but horror stories about the newer stuff. Societally we are getting to this place where reliability and durability is something that's starting to nag at me, and it's interesting to hear I'm not the only one.
I have a veteran friend who is working to get his translator from afghanistan and his family a visa and get them moved over here... he's setting up a little farm so he'll have a place to put them. Same thing. I think people are starting to look over the cliff and worry about what comes after. And building local communities is going to be the ticket.
Saving $1,000 for an emergency fund. Paying down debts one at a time with the “debt snowball” approach.
His advice doesn’t appeal to people who are making a lot of money at all and most of the push back is from people who will give you speeches about compounding interest rather than paying debt.
“Live like no one else, so you can live like no one else.”