News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Warning Signs that Agile Is Declining by jt2190 on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @04:59PM (#3476676)

  The basic problem with the Agile movement is that it took a few 
  proven helpful practices -- almost all of which were well known and 
  often used by experienced software developers before the buzzwords 
  were attached, even if managers didn't realise -- and instead of 
  promoting those, it wrote a "manifesto" so vague that it would make 
  a political speechwriter proud, which didn't actually say anything at 
  all about the practical steps that were useful.
Avoiding creating a list of helpful practices was by design. The signatories of the Agile Manifesto were all very seasoned developers, and like all seasoned developers they knew that a practice that helps in one case harms in another.

You can kind of see how it might go wrong from there:

  * Seasoned developer makes list of helpful practices,
    without providing context, i.e. "Helps in this case,
    harms in this case."
  * Unseasoned developer doesn't understand when and where 
    practice is "helpful", tries to use it in all and every 
    case. Sometimes it works, sometimes it fails.
  * Unseasoned developer who complains: "Helpful practice X
    didn't work for me" is told "You're doing it wrong." 
    Again, no explanation of when and where the practice is
    helpful is provided.
The takeaway here is to always, always, ALWAYS describe the context when describing a solution, i.e. "This is what worked for me, in this situation."
Re:Warning Signs that Agile Is Declining by Silhouette on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @05:25PM (#3476784)
I don't notice any hesitation from those "seasoned developers" when it comes to advocating specific practices elsewhere. According to Bob Martin, if you don't do TDD you're not even professional, for example.
Re:Warning Signs that Agile Is Declining by jt2190 on Friday January 20, 2012 @07:41AM (#3489262)
Yes that's what I was implying. (I guess I wasn't clear enough.) If Bob Martin said something like that, and he couldn't list even _one_ case where TDD wasn't the best approach, I'd question whether he had fully thought out the problem.
Re:Warning Signs that Agile Is Declining by Silhouette on Saturday January 21, 2012 @10:55PM (#3495566)
Bob Martin has said exactly that, without any kind of qualification at all, on many occasions over the past year or two.

Then again, this is the same man who doesn't think there are any more kinds of programming language left to be invented.